I've done around 140 escape rooms across the US, and I'd rate the rooms at EscapeSF as decent, but more like take it or leave it rooms. Still a 5/5 because the rooms are consistently reasonable games.

---Antique Room--- 3 out of 5, but on the lower end of the range. The weakest room I've done at EscapeSF. The first "puzzle" (if you can even call it that) was gimmicky and poorly designed. Other than that, the room was fairly standard. The set was below average, the story was pretty much non-existent, and the puzzles were pretty much what you'd see in other rooms. It's a fine room, but you can take it or leave it.

---Blind Tiger--- The second escape room I've ever done. As a group of 4 newbies, we got only about 2/3 of the way through the room and I left impressed nonetheless, mainly because the automation, set design, and puzzle integration with the set/story made the production value miles above Real Escape's Time Travel Lab. However, nowadays I'd expect this level of tech and puzzles in an average escape room, which makes this room a 3/5.

Set - Multi-room set, where the transition between rooms was fairly logical and smooth. The set didn't have a ton of interesting props or decorations.

Story - Light story that played some amount of significance into the game, which is a bit more than you'd get in most rooms.

Puzzles - Pretty well integrated into the story, but the puzzles were pretty standard overall. Mostly (if not completely) automated with some interesting input mechanisms, which was a plus.

---Space Bus--- The most recent escape room I've done at EscapeSF. 3 out of 5 because it's a solid room, but there's a lack of uniqueness which means it's not super interesting for enthusiasts.

Set - It's a bus, so the space is small. There weren't any super interesting set pieces, though they really did succeed in creating an outer space vibe. I don't recall if there were any motion experiences, which would put the set a notch higher. Nonetheless, the set was reasonable overall but not mind-blowing.

Story - Not a lot of story, as this room was more about solving a bunch of puzzles.

Puzzles - There are a decent number of puzzles in this game, with a space bus manual as your guide (I actually quite like seeing this guidebook/journal element in games, assuming it makes sense within the story, which it did in this case). The puzzles fit well with the space theme, and a couple of them involved unique interactions. I liked that there was a diversity of puzzles.