Dive Bar Pizza — Attraction in Town of East Hampton

A visit here on 8/2/25 with friends was supposed to be a pleasant experience and turned highly negative. Initially, we were looking forward to trying the pizza. However, the experience turned highly negative & confrontational when staff refused to accept valid Colorado IDs for alcohol purchases. Despite the IDs being legitimate, they were rejected, and service was denied, even though the IDs proved otherwise (and we weren’t even trying to buy alcohol). The decision to refuse service, after already engaging with the group and taking their order, seemed arbitrary and unprofessional. New York State law states that valid driver's licenses from any state, including Colorado, are acceptable forms of identification for purchasing alcohol. The staff's refusal to recognize these official documents suggests a lack of training or potentially a misuse of authority, making the experience feel disrespectful and discriminatory. This was a frustrating and demeaning situation. Our group of young vulnerable women was treated unfairly, and the evening was ruined because of the staff's insistence on rejecting valid IDs for reasons that were unfounded. We strongly urge management to review their policies regarding out-of-state IDs and ensure all staff members are properly trained on acceptable forms of identification. A lack of understanding in this area can lead to negative customer experiences and potential discrimination.

Recommendation: Others should be cautious when visiting Dive Bar Pizza, especially when relying on out-of-state IDs. It was extremely unfortunate that a simple pizza outing turned into such a negative and demeaning experience due to what seemed to be an abuse of authority...

★★★★★ A Must-Visit Spot for Delicious Pizza and Great Vibes!

Dive Bar Pizza is an absolute gem in Montauk! The moment you walk in, you're greeted with a lively atmosphere and friendly staff that make you feel right at home.

The pizza here is outstanding. The white pizza with ricotta and caramelized onions is a must-try, offering a perfect balance of flavors. The Grandma's pizza with sauce on top is another standout, showcasing their expertise in creating classic favorites.

Beyond the delicious food, the bar offers a great selection of drinks, and the overall vibe is fun and relaxed. Whether you're stopping by for a quick slice or planning to spend the evening with friends, Dive Bar Pizza caters to all.

Don't forget to bring a Sharpie to leave your mark on the tables or walls—a fun tradition that adds to the charm of the place.

For anyone in the Montauk area, Dive Bar Pizza is a must-visit. Highly...

Was recommended this place for a slice of pizza and understood that it was bar as well as a pizza place but I quite frankly do not think it excuses a thing that occurred. We ordered one plain pizza , got our number, and went to sit at a table outside. An hour passes, no pizza. We are actively watching people come in and leave with pizzas within 15-20 minutes. Sent someone from our group to check on the pizza, "Oh it's gonna be another hour wait, we're a little behind". Two hours for a plain pizza. Immediately got a refund and took our pizza search elsewhere. In what world should a singular plain pizza take two hours and in what world do you not tell the person ordering that it will...