NY Cake-Baking Supply Store-Yonkers — Local services in City of Yonkers

I usually go to the store in the city, but since they’re temporarily closed, I had to order online to pick up at their Yonkers location for a rush order. First, I got there at 4p, their closing time, however, nobody even noticed or cared or tried to rush me out. Pick up is so simple, not an annoying process to confirm identity or wait for someone to bring it down, everything’s right there. I also forgot to add items to my order before I got there, which wasn’t a problem at all. I just told the guy what I wanted, and he came back with it. I didn’t have to swipe my card or anything. He simply let me walk out with it right away and they take care of charging it to your order after. (He was handsome AF too lol). Ive always loved NY Cake, but I hate ordering online but after stopping by their warehouse, I won’t be so hesitant to order online and even have them ship to me without worrying because their customer service great and they have the best supplies I’ve yet to find in the...

Have an emergency and need baking supplies asap THIS IS NOT THE PLACE FOR YOU! This is the second time I order from NYCAKES warehouse in Yonkers and have had a problem with my order. I thought it would be more efficient and convenient to shop from since I live in the boarder of Yonkers and the Bronx but I was so wrong. Customer service is poor, don't expect the manager to care much about your order or your time being wasted with the numerous back and fourth trips because they didn't get it right the first time. Bad enough that a lot of there products are ridiculously overpriced. I'm just better off ordering from Amazon and baking supply...

I used to shop their Manhattan location back when I lived on Roosevelt Island, but I moved to the north Bronx and needed a last minute tall cake box so I decided to give the warehouse a try. Ordering online and picking up from the Yonkers warehouse was SO easy and convenient! I placed my order online, jumped in the car, and as soon as I arrived not even half an hour later, they were handing me my order right at the front. I'm never lugging into Manhattan to get my specialty baking items ever again. If you live anywhere near the warehouse and are into no fuss, easy shopping for your baking needs, this is the...