Payfair Supermarket — Local services in Islamorada

Worst customer service. Price on our item did not ring up as the advertised price on the shelf tag. She rolled her eyes at me when i mentioned the price difference and said that the prices on the shelf tag were a hundred years old. My husband went back to look at the item and found 3 different price tags on the same item. She then accused us of changing prices.We just moved into the neighbourhood and will not return again to be verbal abused by such a...

It's the friendly neighborhood market everyone remembers from childhood whether you grew up in Tavernier or not. The produce is local whenever possible. They have the best meat in town, organic and gluten free foods. The deli makes huge, scrumptious sandwiches and subs to order. A great place to get quality food for yourself, your out-of -town company and call in orders for your Super Bowl parties or a day...

Payfair is the skilled local butcher we turn to for everything from burger meat to giant roasts. They do some aging which is a wonderful service that's hard to find. They also provide expert advice with a smile. The rest of the grocery, while small, usually has what you need to complete your meal or a basic shopping trip. Check hours...