Dulce de Leche Cake Shop — Local services in Town of Islip

This bakery designed and perfected the cake exactly how I wanted it. This bakery was not my first pick because I had no idea about it until my co-worker recommended me to them!! This was my first time ordering from Dulce de Leche Cake Shop, so I honestly took the risk of not knowing if it was even going to taste good because I just wanted the outside of the cake to look how I imagined it. Thank god that I went with my gut because not only did the cake look great from the out side, it tasted amazing! I got so many compliments at the reception from not only my guests but from the venue’s staff of how beautiful the cake came out! The cake even tastes great 3 days later, refrigerated. The cake was vanilla with Raspberry mousse layered with milk chocolate mousse for 2-tiers and the bottom tier was chocolate ganache and cookies and cream layered. I can not wait to order my son’s first birthday cake from here. Thank you Dolce de...

This bakery is by far the best bakery I’ve ever dealt with. The cakes and pastries are AMAZING and the baker puts her whole heart into her creations. She made the most BEAUTIFUL three tier cake for my daughters sweet 16, it tasted even better than it looked, and that’s saying a lot because the cake was ABSOLUTELY breathtaking. I have a wedding and 2 parties to do and this is the ONLY place I’m going for the cakes. I’m a party planner and I will only use this bakery. EVERYONE is ALWAYS AMAZED at the cakes!!!!

I just saw my review from 2016 and I still have the same to say about this bakery. I just picked up a carrot cake for my nephews birthday and a few pastries. I went in for one thing and always come out with more than I expected, I’m going to order a Graduation cake for my daughter and I can’t wait to see and taste it....

I had a horrible experience at Dulce De Leche Cake Shop, which I thought would be perfect for my wedding cake. Unfortunately, the baker was extremely rude and spoke to us in a loud and unpleasant manner. She even claimed to be the owner and said she didn't care about our needs or requests. To make matters worse, she took away the sample cakes that my mom and I were still eating. When we tried to discuss the situation calmly, she only escalated the argument and eventually told us to go to a different bakery. All we wanted to do was try more flavors, but instead, we were met with terrible service and disrespect.

I prefer to give my money to another bakery that provides everything, especially a high service.

Do not go there if you don't want the woman to yell at you...