Remember Yesteryears Vintage Center — Local services in Town of Islip

I've been to this place a few times and even bought a few items. It's very big and has an extensive inventory of all things old and not so old.

Someone from a group I belong to mentioned that the owner will buy just about anything 'antique' so I brought in three items / signs to hang on the wall. One was a Budweiser glass bar sign that needed cleaning, one was a fabric map of Long Island that also needed cleaning and one was a large nautical themed item with TITANIC on it.

The owner said with the cleaning involved he could give me $30 for all three. My late husband acquired these so I had no idea what they were worth, I counted on being give a fair price.

I went into the store today and there was the Titanic sign hanging up with a price of $175 needless to say I was not pleased and left without the item I had intended to buy.

So if you're looking for a bargain you may get it there but I'd caution anyone to be careful about selling anything there.

I take full responsibility for not doing more research and being...

The amount of stuff they have here is astounding and you will find yourself at times at bit overwhelmed at the sheer quantity. They have everything, and I mean everything. They have old video game consoles, to clothings, to postcards, to lamps and furniture and more. If you’re looking for something specific, you might be out of luck as the best way to shop here is to wander aimlessly until something catches your eye, be it cool, something you need, something from your childhood, or something humorous. The prices range from reasonable to ‘Why tf is that so expensive’ but thats standard for every thrift store. The staff are also nice and will help direct towards something your looking for, though as they are all vendors, they will try to advertise what they have to you for uncomfortably long times if you show the slightest interest in anything they have.

Overall, its a great place to go for casual thrifting and just want to see if they have anything...

Love this place! With over 125 different vendors you’re sure to find a unique variety of vintage and antique curiosities! The prices vary as each vendor sets their own prices, but I find prices here to be fair market value and much more comparable to tag sale prices than antique store prices. Consideration should be given that each vendor does the physical footwork to obtain each item in the wild and some travel far and wide for these one of a kind treasures.

You’ll find anything from antique toys to timeless furniture pieces... and even some vintage upscale Gucci, Tiffany and Prada items! Everything you’ll need to decorate your Farmhouse or Shabby Chic Garden is there... there’s even a nice assortment of vintage jewelry...