La Supreme Pizza — Restaurant in Town of Islip

Moved to Oakdale earlier this year and was looking for a new, local pizza spot to knock out my cravings. My friend suggested I try La Supreme. First thing I ordered was a buffalo chicken pizza, extra cheese, add jalapenos (yes, for myself, don't judge me). My God, it was amazing. Naturally, I kept going back. All of the specialty slices I've had have been outstanding. Highly recommend the mac and cheese slice, chipotle chicken, and chicken vodka slices. To to top it off, the staff members are all incredibly friendly. One of the reasons my friend recommended them in the first place. He pointed out that they don't have that typical "edgy New York pizza place attitude," which you may get from a lot of others. Will be returning again and again and writing this review made me hungry so maybe you'll...

Pizza on Long Island is pretty much always guaranteed to be good and it can be hard to stand out, La Supreme does not suffer from this problem. They are known throughout the area for great pizza, amazing customer service, and fair pricing compared to the competition. I have also been pleasantly surprised by their non pizza options, such as wings and heroes which are on par with any other restaurant. I highly recommend trying a specialty pie and picking up your order just to interact with the always...

We love there Mac and cheese pizza and that's why we always only get it and will continue too but so when we brought the pizza home last night and when I finally opened it it was just a regular pizza, I know what I ordered and I had a witness who heard me order, so the guys there who take the orders need to wait till after work to get stoned, from now on I will have the person read back my order and we will be checking the pizza before we leave there, we love you guys but c'mon pick...