Warsaw C Store — Local services in Town of Warsaw

I give it a solid 4.5 out of 5. The pizza I got was specialty, it was a total of $25.91. Now, coming from a very picky eater and someone who is very critical of pizza, my favorite food, I think their pizza earns a solid 90%. Its half the price of Batavia Main street pizza for a smaller size, but a lot of toppings. It is by no means perfect, but the pizza is homemade and you can see them make it, its decent, the staff are very kind, I think the taste to price ratio is very good. Its not perfect, but its good. I think maybe drop the price by a couple dollars if you want to compete effectively with Stefano's or 7 Eleven. I also advise checking the pizza about halfway through the expected cook time, and then at 3/4's of the expected time to determine roughly how much longer it needs. Its my preferred pizza for in town and out of town, with the exception of Wegman's. I think you guys and girls honestly deserve a 4.5 to 4.8 rating....

We bought a LG pizza with cheese, sweet sauce, cup and char pepperoni, and mushroom on half. More than half of the pepperoni was bad. White spots on it. Will think about ordering there again. After a phone conversation with the manager(Ally) she made us a new pizza and explained what had happened. She even included the extra pizza that I asked for. The second time was much better and we will...

Do not get pizza here. I went to pick up pizza at the allotted time. They said there had been an accident it would be another 20 mins. I said that was no way to run a business and he went off on me swearing telling me that not serving me would bring in another 10 customers. Very unprofessional and the girl making the pizza was giggling and laughing. So if you want a pizza or sub DO NOT...