Jeff Johnson & Co — Local services in Upper Arlington

How am I only the second review on here!? My fiancée knows me enough to let me select my own engagement ring. I've never shopped for anything like this before so I looked online and went to at least 5 stores... while all the jewelers (including the big names around) were nice, there were several things that made Jeff Johnson and Co stand out: -They had rings that were different than what everyone else had. Yes, they had the popular styles, but they also carried the vintage style and die-struck pieces manufactured by the Whitehouse Brothers out of Cincinnati - which is what I ended up selecting and have received so many compliments on how special it looks. -They also make some of their own jewelry and you can see their work stations within the store, which is really neat. -Bang for our buck. Let me tell you, this is a WOW exclamation piece of jewelry. It's just stunning, and I feel like I got more for our money than what I saw at the other stores. But most importantly, I am am tickled happy about the ring we got. I definitely recommend...

Okay, so my jeweler that I had gone to for years moved. I looked around for another jeweler and was sent to Jeff Johnson & Company. I was very hesitant at leaving my ring anywhere as my husband had it made for me. From the moment I walked into this jewelry store I knew that they would take care of my ring. Billie assured me that my ring would be safe and they would repair my loose emerald and that they would call me when it was done. I felt very good about leaving my ring with them. Billie actually called me much sooner than anticipated that my ring was ready to be picked up. I went to pick up my ring and wow, it looks brand new. I’m very happy with my repair! They repaired my emerald setting beautifully. I do not live close to Jeff Johnson & Co. but let me tell you they are my new jeweler. I am very happy with them and Billie was great to work with! Thank you for your care and compassion! Leaving a sentimental piece of jewelry with someone new can be stressful, but rest assured, this jeweler will take...

The experience of working with JJ&Co. is second to none. I was involved in the creation of my fiancé’s engagement ring every step of the way. And now every time I look at the ring on my fiancé’s finger, I don’t just see a ring, I see a masterpiece that was inspired by our individual story and points towards our bright future together.

The artisans and staff at JJ&Co. are like a second family to us. They know our story, our style, our likes, and dislikes. And as someone who’s always dreaded jewelry stores because of stressful high-pressure sales situations, I have to say that JJ&Co. couldn’t be further from this. Unlike other jewelers out there, JJ&Co. isn’t looking to just make money and move on. They’re genuinely looking out for our best interests and work right alongside us to craft the best possible piece of jewelry for us that fits the budget we have.

I couldn’t recommend JJ&Co. more. They’re the most hard-working and honest individuals I’ve ever worked with, and they’re the best at what...