Tito's Pizza Erin — Restaurant in Erin

Pros: Their team was very friendly and energetic, the atmosphere of this new pizza joint looked clean and bright. Compared to their competitors in town their pricing is much more affordable than some of the others which is appreciated. I think this is a big plus, they definitely don't skimp on the toppings they were plentiful and fresh.

Cons: The dough, unfortunately isn't memorable there wasn't much flavor to it but in terms of the consistency it was chewy in the middle and crunchy on the outside.

Our biggest disappointment was the amount of cheese they used (we didn't ask for extra), normally I wouldn't say no to cheese but when the cheese is thicker than the thin crust pizza it's sitting on its less enjoyable to eat and more like a chore. In my opinion great pizza is "less is more", I would've liked to have tasted the sauce and the toppings but everything was overpowered by the amount of cheese.

I am strong believer that when starting a new business it takes iteration and customer feedback to fine tune that perfect experience, and I think this team will pull it off and I will definitely come back...

just ordered this yesterday and I have to say that the pizza is alright I would give it a 7/10 not "the best in town" as the sign says which is also a bold thing to say being so new with other better pizza places to go to. one good thing is the deal they had for $20 but other then that I have no idea what the menu is because every tv they had was off and really had only one option at that point. One thing I did not like at all was there wings because what a joke and a half they were. They were half fried and half soggy? I don't really know how that happens but the meat itself was ok. Now he sauce on the wings was terrible because they said it was barbecue sauce on the wings but then I tasted them and I knew it was no name spaghetti sauce mixed with hot sauce from the grocery store right beside them. I would give the wings a 2/10 and would love to give a better review to this place but to do that they need to be making better food and not cheap out on...

Disappointing Experience

I decided to stop by Tito’s after not having a slice for a few years—unfortunately, it was a letdown from the start. I walked in and received no greeting. No “hello,” no acknowledgment—nothing.

I asked how long the pizza had been sitting before ordering a slice, and was told “about an hour.” After taking a few bites, it was clear that wasn’t accurate. The slice was dry, tough, and clearly had been sitting out much longer.

While I sat down to eat, the woman at the counter kept laughing and staring at me, which made the experience even more uncomfortable. It felt like something was wrong with the pizza, or like I was being watched for the wrong reasons.

To add to the confusion, I later realized the woman behind the counter spoke very little English—if any. Every question I asked was met with a simple head nod, with no real communication or clarity.

Overall, it was an awkward and unwelcoming visit. I won’t...