Brothers Tavern — Restaurant in Sicamous

I was told to expect an incredible pizza experience here and that the food was supposedly very good here, I’ve learned by painful experience though that most dining experiences in Sicamous are dismal and disappointing although in this instance the service was good although a little disorganized and the atmosphere was very nice, bright and airy with lots of room and a great deck area. I wanted to stay and enjoy a pint or two but it wasn’t in the cards instead I decided to order two pizzas one Canadian style and one purely vegetarian simple enough, I paid for my pizzas and was told it would take twenty minutes, I wasn’t offered a place to sit or even a glass of water so I sat in my car to wait after twenty minutes I returned and asked for my pizzas, complete confusion erupted and they were unable to locate my order or the waitress that had taken the order, fortunately I had paid for the order and had proof that I had ordered it, they assured me that in yet another twenty minutes I would have my pizzas so again I wasn’t offered a place to sit or a glass of water, I returned to my car in 38 degree heat to wait. After another sweltering 20 minutes I returned to the counter and this time they were able to provide my pizzas to me although they attempted to bill me a second time… after working through that I was able to return home approximately an hour after ordering my take out pizzas. We eagerly opened our pizza boxes and began eating only to find that the pizzas although amply covered with ingredients were undercooked, the crust was doughy and the centre of the pizzas were essentially raw inside, although the cheese on top looked cooked so I’m not certain how they accomplished this. Repeated calls to the restaurant were not picked up or rang busy, so we ended up cooking the individual pieces of pizza in the air fryer so our experience with this supposedly amazing pizza was amazingly underwhelming. Don’t get me wrong I do believe that this place has potential (unlike the some of the other pubs in Sicamous) they just need to get organized to make things happen properly. As a local I’d like to be able to not have to leave Sicamous for a good restaurant experience and I had high hopes for Brothers Tavern, nice place, okay prices, so so atmosphere it’s just the cooks that messed up and the staff in the delivery to a waiting customer

Well I decided to give this place one more try in 2024! I phoned before meeting my out of town colleague there. We were greeted and told to stay closer to the bar to stay warm as the place was sub zero, and the only customers there were huddled around the bar drinking with the staff and listening to ancient 80’s Rock, I never removed my jacket and any food ordered was immediately cold. I tried ordering their “Canadian” pizza which when received was horribly overcooked and tasted like frozen supermarket pizza with bacon bits on it, probably one of the worst pizzas I’ve ever had, pretty terrible and underwhelming I did order some Buffalo wings and received wings with a weird white/orange sauce on it and then when I asked I was told that’s how the Buffalo wings here are served although it makes no mention of a Ranch/Franks hot sauce mix in the menu? Meh won’t be ordering that again tried my fish taco’s which were basically soft taco shells with an over cooked and dark brown Captain Highliner fish stick and salsa, wow a Chimpanzee could have done a better job of preparing this and at least could have changed the oil in the deep fryer before cooking this. Service was slow and our we could smell liquor on the breath of the waitress. Never was offered a refill on our drinks or how’s the food inquiry just here’s your bill as the waitress was obviously distracted by her friends at the bar. I can’t in all good conscience recommend this place to anyone I’ve tried to support this place but it seems no one here is willing to try to even give marginally good service and consistent good food, disappointing as the options for local restaurants is...

Sure! I recently had the pleasure of dining at Brothers Tavern, and I must say, it was an outstanding experience from start to finish. The moment I walked in, I was greeted warmly by the friendly staff, setting a welcoming tone for the evening.

Ambiance: The ambiance of Brothers Tavern is cozy and inviting. The rustic decor, coupled with modern touches, creates a perfect setting for a relaxed meal. Whether you're there for a casual lunch or a special dinner, the atmosphere makes you feel right at home.

Service: The service was impeccable. Our server was attentive, knowledgeable, and genuinely enthusiastic about the menu. They took the time to explain the specials of the day and offered excellent recommendations based on our preferences. The staff's attention to detail and commitment to ensuring a pleasant dining experience did not go unnoticed.

Food: The food at Brothers Tavern is nothing short of exceptional. We started with the house-made appetizers, which were fresh and bursting with flavor. For the main course, I opted for the [insert main dish here], and it was cooked to perfection. The ingredients were high-quality, and the presentation was beautiful. My companions were equally impressed with their dishes, including the [insert other dish here] and the [insert other dish here].

Drinks: The drink selection was diverse, with a variety of craft beers, fine wines, and creative cocktails. The bartender clearly knows their craft, as our drinks were well-balanced and expertly crafted.

Overall: Brothers Tavern exceeded my expectations in every way. The combination of delicious food, excellent service, and a welcoming atmosphere made for a memorable dining experience. I highly recommend Brothers Tavern to anyone looking for a top-notch meal in a comfortable setting. I will definitely be...

Attended this Pub on Wednesday night and it was busy and probably because of the beer.... Was told food would be an hour wait which was quite ok... Five people in our group and we ordered shareables... 2 ceaser salads.. about five orders of wings.. 2 orders of bruschetta and one order of chicken tenders and fries...

The server and service were excellent and friendly. The beers were good and the best thing was the ceaser salad... very good! The point of ordering shareables was to eat in stages... salad then bruschetta then wings etc. It all came at once... had to pull up an extra table to fit all the plates... even that part was ok.

The wings which were on special were the worst we have ever had! Small and dried out like they have been in the fryer for the 3rd time! Lots of flavors if you just like dunking in whatever sauce you ordered... We have had better and more juicier wings from the grocery store deli...Same goes for chicken tenders dried out and in the fryer 3 times? The bruschetta topping was good but the bread/toast was rock hard and stale... barely editable... the ceaser salad croutons were less stale! Because we are traveling and hungry we ate it reagardless mind you with a little extra beer to wash it down.. Took home the remaining wings.. not sure why... tossed them in the trash... they wouldn't be any better reheated 4 times... Wouldn't go here again or recommend it unless for...