New York Pizza — Restaurant in Amsterdam

Hi. In April 2025, I placed one order here. I don't often order from NY Pizza, but I generally like their products very much.

My order consisted of a 4 cheese, 40 cm NY Style Pizza, and x20 crispy chicken wings, for takeout.

The ready time was quick, like under 15 minutes, maybe even under 10 minutes, and it matched very well with the time window they shared via the website.

Visually, all looked good. See the pics of the boxes and how the food looked in them. Taste, however, was a disappointment for me.

The pizza seemed to have all ingredients, but was bland. No taste; I don't know how that happens. Also, the garlic sauce that I ordered on the borders (is standard) seemed to have no effect, as if it was absent. I don't know why I ate this pizza.

The crispy chicken wings had a delicious taste of the crust, like, that is the target taste. However, it wasn't well stuck to the meat. It was, in part, piling off on its own as the wings moved, and it was too easy to separate them. The meat was on the verge of what I could eat. I am not an expert, and I want to believe they prepped the meat well, but it was again so bland (also as chicken), and maybe the word is watery that, again, I wondered why I would eat it. It was edible, but not something enjoyable.

My stomach wasn't happy with it, but I had no problems after eating these products. Altogether, I can't give this experience...

Again a badly prepared order. This time with a completely over-baked, tasteless and dry pizza. After calling they promised to send over a new pizza immediately. An hour later I have to call again because they clearly forgot. Without an apology they promise that now it's really coming right away. Takes another 40 minutes, only for them to deliver the wrong pizza! Also no apologies for the time delay or anything. Never ordering at...

They make very good pizzas. I don't know that why people rate them bad. They put enough toppings on the pizza. Only bad thing about their pizza is that it is very oily and unhealthy. Every time i eat from New York pizza i get chest burns because of the spicy toppings they put in the pizza. Try hot vegetable pizza. Its Tasty!...