Bonnie Lee Creamery Ice Cream Parlor — Restaurant in Andover

I’ve been here twice and both times had sundaes. One banana split and one caramel chocolate sundae (that is no longer offered). It seems that the idea of the shop is to match flavor with flavor, which is the culinary equivalent of rhyming a word with the same word.

My chocolate and caramel sundae was chocolate and caramel ice cream with chocolate and caramel syrup. A banana split is usually vanilla ice cream with strawberry, chocolate, and pineapple topping. Their banana split is strawberry ice cream with strawberry topping, chocolate ice cream with chocolate topping, and, I think, the pineapple topping was on vanilla. No creativity.

The spot is cozy and clean. Downtown Andover is classic Americana and this ice cream shop fits right in. The staff is friendly and I didn’t wait too long either time. While I would never request/expect this spot to go “gourmet”, it might serve them well to just Google some ice cream recipes to easily enhance flavor pairings and create some varieties on the menu. I think that could be fun for them, as well as...

We stopped at Bonnie Lee's for a snack after feeding the carp. We loved our ice cream choices.

When exited our car near Bonnie Lee's in Andover, OH townsquare, I expected Doc Brown and Marty McFly to zoom down road in their Delorean off on another adventure.

Bonnie Lee's Creamery fits right into the quaint nostalgic townsquare of Andover. Bonnie Lee's herself scooped our ice cream while we chatted with locals waiting their turn at the counter.

It was great ice cream on a hot...

Bonnie Lee Creamery is a must visit destination if you are a fan of really, really good ice cream. We tried 3 flavors : Amaretto Cherry, PB Brownies & Lemon Cheesecake. The flavors in each one were perfectly balanced and true to their names. Delicious. I love ice cream and I visit many shops - I'm putting this with a couple others at the top of my list. Well...