Fatte's Pizza of Atascadero — Restaurant in Atascadero

Decent pizza, not great customer service. I inquired about the prices for a two topping versus a four topping pizza, because every other pizza shop I've ever gone to charges per topping. The girl on the phone just kept saying they are both "regular pizzas" without giving context or pricing and said "so I basically answered your question" in an annoyed voice.. I said she did not answer my question at all actually. Then with even more of a rude tone she finally explained that "regular pizza" means they have unlimited toppings and it's all the same price. I guess they just expect you to know this if you're not a regular customer? I looked online at the menu prior to my call, but didn't see any prices. I'm sorry, but now I am annoyed. Maybe their manager/shift supervisors can better train the employees to have more proper and effective order taking etiquette, so these lackluster interactions can be avoided when new customers don't know...

We had very bad experience today. Too bad because the pizza is actually good. Ordered pizzas for graduation dinner with family visiting. Ordered one that was supposed to be gluten free. Confirmed over phone and was told we must order large. Ordered. We picked up order and began dinner and it wasn’t gluten free. Called and they first said they could give me 20% off next order. I said no, I would like refund for pizza cause it won’t be eaten. Said the would replace but I had to pay more for the gf crust. The one we already ordered and didn’t get. So they wanted me to drive 10 minutes back to pick up a pizza and charge me more when they admitted it was their error. Plus we ordered a side and paid and it wasn’t included in order. Ridiculous. You make an error and admit it then want to charge me more. Plus, if member of my house had eaten the order they would have been sick. Very bad...

🍕🌟🌟🌟🌟 Fattes Pizza – No-Frills, Totally Hits the Spot

Fattes Pizza is one of those spots you don’t overthink—you just order, eat, and enjoy. The Double Cheese is melty, simple, and exactly what you want when you’re not in the mood for anything fancy. I also really liked the Sticky Fingers—sweet, spicy, and totally addictive. Even the Hawaiian was solid if you’re into that sweet-and-savory vibe.

It’s not gourmet, but it’s not trying to be. The crust is decent, the toppings are generous, and you get a lot of food for the price. Perfect for a chill night in or feeding a hungry crew without breaking the bank.

If you’re looking for good pizza that doesn’t pretend to be something it’s...