Julio's Pizza Co. — Restaurant in Atlantic Highlands

I thought I’ve reviewed Julio’s but apparently I didn’t on Google. I’ve ordered from every pizzeria in Middletown and most of the surrounding area over the past 20 years. Julio’s is hands down the best - not only their food, but from their owners down to their delivery drivers. If I ever had an issue (which were few in my dozens of orders over the last year) - it was rectified immediately and personally. Their pizza is perfection. It’s consistent and made with care. Their Sicilian is great - the right amount of crunch and fluff. And their Neapolitan pies are perfect - not too thin or thick. Their sauce and cheese is amazing. Their subs are awesome too. Honestly their ingredients are super high quality and that along with their chefs, makes incredible pies. I know their pickle pizza is the signature but the pepperoni, onion and hot honey is amazing and so is the sausage pepper onion pie. You won’t be disappointed in this place. They’ve recently celebrated their 3rd anniversary I believe and I hope there are many more to come. Thank you for being my family’s pizzeria. Shout out to their driver who is a Bills fan!

Trust me - go extra large!...

Excellent pizza!! A small (very small) independent pizza restaurant. We had 2 large NY style pepperoni pizzas and loved them. The garlic knots were extremely small, but were good. The prices were on par, if not cheaper, than most places. The closest chain I can compare it to nationally is Sbarro, but Julio’s is better in my opinion, plus I always enjoy supporting local businesses that provide variety and do it right. Inside the seating is limited. For dining in, the most people at 1 table is 4 people, and there are about 5 tables along the wall, and a counter table with a few bar stools that face the window to the main street . The restaurant was clean, including the bathroom. I’d definitely...

Stopped by for a slice with my mother in law since we were in the area and I must say it was quite amazing. No pizzeria in the area could compare to Julio’s Pizza Co. their sauce was flavorful,the cheese was good, and the crust was that perfect light crisp consistency that is ideal for any pizza lover. Their Small menu keeps it simple and makes it easier to decide. I also ordered an Italian sandwich which I couldn’t have been happier with. Loaded with meat and cheese it filled me up way too quick. The service was amazing especially the very pretty new girl working the register who helped me around their unique menu items such as their pickle pizza and their dip n’ dough appetizer. 10/10...