American Pie Pizzeria — Restaurant in Barnesville

If you are looking for a decent pizza buffet with a decent selection of pizza, this is a good place for that. I have never been disappointed with the food here, but some should note this is probably the greasiest of the pizza you can get in Barnesville. If you're a local who still hasn't come in to the new location, don't worry the quality hasn't changed. A couple of issues to note. 1st and this is a big one for me, the new location has tons of space, but the buffet area (where you get your pizza) barely if at all utilizes that space, so just like in the old location it can get very, very congested when multiple people are trying to partake of the buffet. Next, the seating. There are only so many seats with normal back supporting chairs (drastically more than the last location which is a marked improvement), if it's crowded you are going to have to sit at a stool which might cause some discomfort for many customers. My favorite slice? Chicken...

We have been eating here almost every Monday night for a year for their dinner buffet. We also eat there quite often for the lunch buffet, and then when we were building our house we called in pizza or calzones for pick up a ton. We also generally order here to feed a bunch of people after we do our races for Southeast Mini Moto. Basically... we eat a lot of American Pie. They pizza and calzones are all amazing. The last couple of months the dinner buffet was having problems and I finally reached out to the owners and let them know what all we were experiencing with service, food, etc. The next week when we went the owners had taken that feedback and fixed the problems we were having. It is back to being the great American Pie we know and love. I highly recommend the loaded potato pizza or Calzone. It is amazing! Also, their sweet tea is great!! They are pricier than other pizza places, but we think it has...

So we ordered 5 pizzas 2 orders of Buffalo Chips and 1 order of Butter Balls tonight from here I go to pick them up and they say $130.00 I said that’s not correct we order from the menu that’s online and the price states $ 11.99 they say it’s $ 19.99 each and tells me that not there advertisement same address same number to I placed the order but they say it’s not there’s and they have this problem a lot . I told them that’s deceiving the customers if it’s not yours then you should state that to the customers when placing orders. I should have just left everyone of them sitting there but was already running late for a Birthday Party. I’m awaiting to talk to the owner about the situation. Also to the young ladies working the window you should at least wait until the customers leave before you start laughing about it . Very unprofessional. Not good...