Beaufort Baking Company — Restaurant in Beaufort

My first experience with Beaufort Baking Company was when my mom brought me a key lime pie “just because”. Normally I hesitate to tell my mom when something is good, because it tends to turn into Costco sized deliveries of said item. Y’all. This pie was so dang good I texted her and said “that’s the best key lime pie I’ve ever had, you can keep those things coming”. The graham cracker crust is dense and just a tad salty, and the filling is a very real lime flavor with plenty of tartness, not too much sweet.

So of course I’ve had a few since then, my husband is on the bandwagon for them too. He’s got a mean sweet tooth, but this pie is so rich that after he went for his second slice, he had to stop because he said the pie “beat” him. Never in my life have I witnessed a dessert beat that man.

Do their products get better? The answer is yes, but I couldn’t imagine how. I’ll tell you how. Their Down East Lemon Pie (tart lemon filling with a saltine cracker crust) and the Oreo cookie (some sort of sugar cookie with crushed up Oreos folded in), that’s how. Speechless, y’all. Best pies and cookies I’ve ever had. I don’t know how my waist line will survive this winter at the rate I’m going.

I’m not sure how well known this place is, since my friends hadn’t heard of it. But if y’all aren’t selling out of everything daily, you deserve to be.

Other info unrelated to the desserts: this is a counter service, take-your-goods-out-with-you type of place…at least I didn’t see any seating but maybe I was just on a mission with tunnel vision to get my hands on the dang pie. I’ll probably start calling ahead to ask for special ordered pie, just so I can guarantee one for myself and not risk the trip “over the bridge” and come...

I cannot say enough good things about this bakery! They made the smash cake and cupcakes for my baby’s first birthday, and everything was absolutely perfect. From start to finish, they were so easy to work with—great communication, quick responses, and they brought my design ideas to life beautifully. The cake and cupcakes not only looked amazing, but were also ready on time and very reasonably priced. I truly appreciated how stress-free they made the process during such a busy time. I will definitely be ordering from them again for future...

Unbelievable! I have lived all over and tried bakeries from here to New York. This place is top shelf, next level good. The Oatmeal cream pie just recently changed my life haha chefs kiss. 10/10 HIGHLY RECOMMEND CANT...