Supremo's Pizzeria - (Callery)Evans City — Restaurant in Callery

Now I mean this is the nicest way… but how does this place stay open. Now hear me out on this. It’s affordable, delicious, they have modern technology, they are well staffed during a pandemic, they are impeccably clean, had outdoor seating before it was cool, the drinks are fresh and fizzy and didn't roll around in the back of an owners 02 Toyota Tacoma like other pizza places. If it was possible to maintain this standard other places would do it too. I am assuming the second location is the first of many and these guys have cracked the pizza code. It might have something to do with being located next to the town baseball field, and above a dance and gymnastics place, and you share a patio with a local brew house that plays live music, But you could put this place in moon, Mars... or any other astrologically named neighborhood and I would go there. This place is that old friend who shows up every time you need them and has never let you down. Will even listen to you complain about other girls.. I mean pizza places when you stupidly venture out and get your heart broken only to realize the modest, put together pizza place you grew up with is perfect after it takes off its glasses and shakes out its hair. Never change.

** Pro Tip: Get twice as much pizza, take one home, refrigerate it. When you’re ready to eat the leftovers throw on some crushed red pepper and extra pepperonis then bake it in a convection oven on 400 for 5 minutes. Not only is it amazing… it’s better than the original. Crisps up like that old catholic school fish fry pizza that lives in our memories with your grandma and Christmas morning. If I’m not eating it fresh, I’m eating it tomorrow. It’s too good to waste on room...

i got the wife an italian sub, there was mostly and i mean mostly lettuce on it. There was hardly any meat or tomatoes on it.All you could taste was lettuce and the bun. I got a hot sausage and it was so messy I couldn't hold it. I had to use a knife and fork, and it was very very bland. We ordered provolone sticks and got these little triangles instead of sticks. Which by the way were very super bland, there was no flavor at all to them. For the money they charged the food should at least have flavor to it. ORDER AT YOUR OWN RISK ! We have been ordering from there since they opened because they had really good food. It is now time to find a place that doesn't want to lose good customers. BYE BYE SUPREMOS ! We thought we would give them another chance and once again a MAJOR LET DOWN !!!!!!!! Order 2 club hoagies, the wife's was good. Mine only had 2 very thin slices of turkey, cheese, and veggies. I guarantee there will never be another chance. I don't like...

Ok so I've never eaten here before tonight. Ordered a pretty big delivery order of appetizers. Friday night so I expected it to be pretty busy. It took them like 27 minutes to get our food to us. I was already impressed by that. Then I start opening everything to check it. Everything looked great. But the taste test is by far the most important. Everything was delicious! You have to try the JALAPENO BITES! They are the best I've had anywhere. Pepperoni bites were great also. Breadsticks are delicious and so are the pretzel sticks. Fried Ravioli was also perfect. I was seriously impressed by everything. I ordered pizza 2 weeks ago from another local place and had a really bad experience. I couldn't even believe the food I got. It was terrible. Supremo's was the complete opposite. Couldn't be more satisfied. Try this place out. Highly...