Johnny & Mike's Pizza — Restaurant in Carlisle

Confusing experience. The restaurant has 2 names- Johnny & Mike's and Stadium View. We weren't acknowledged when entering so chose a table. The tables had a code to scan into your phone to read the menu. It didn't work so we asked for a paper menu after flagging someone down.

The menu had pizza, sandwiches, appetizers, pasta, salads. No descriptions of items meaning 'The Timmy' pizza didn't say what was on it. Or the 'Waylon' sandwich had no details of ingredients.

We ordered onion rings, salads, pizza. Creamy parm dressing super yummy. The salads had a few pepperoni added which was a nice touch. Onion rings had good flavor, slightly overcooked for our taste. Pizza excellent! Crispy, thin crust, generous toppings.

The staff did not check in with us after delivering food (all came at once). Didn't offer drink refills. Didn't bring to go containers. We saw other tables getting up and helping themselves to napkins, to go boxes, etc. Walking to the bar to ask for drink refills (including kids for water and pop refills). Maybe that's their thing. It was confusing to us.

Our bill was $47. That was for a large pizza, onion rings, 2 salads, and a pitcher of beer. We had half the pizza to take home.

The pizza was very good- we would order that for takeout sometime...

I can't speak to the service as we went on a Wednesday and they do fund raising on Wednesdays. I admire the thought but they people need to know how to do basic waiter/waitress stuff. Moving on to the food, this is a small town mom and pop shop. Usually these places are really good or have a special niche. I would say that the best part of our meal was the Chicken Fettuccine pizza and that was mediocre. The crust tastes like something that is store-bought and defrosted. My son got macaroni and cheese kids meal and there was very little mac and cheese in the dish and then he got a cookie that was burnt. With this being our first experience I believe it will also be...

This place is amazing! Tonight was my first time ordering from here. I had it delivered, I was quoted 45 minutes which is normal. I received my large sausage and pepperoni pizza and sampler appetizer in 18 minutes! They're fairly priced as well. The sampler platter comes with fried mushrooms, mozzarella sticks, onion rings, and jalapeno poppers - which were amazing!! The pizza is great as well! Altogether my order came to $26!! I'm very pleased with how quickly it arrived and the delivery driver was very nice! He gave my 4 year old daughter a high-five!! I will definitely be getting food...