Greeks Pizzeria 96th and College — Restaurant in Carmel

Popped in Thursday after work to pick up a pie. The gentleman behind the counter warmly acknowledged that I had walked in, told me professionally that it would just a moment as he was finishing a task, then grabbed my pie and sticks, handed it to me with a smile and thanked me for my business. Like -- like he was the owner or something. But he was probably 18 so it seems unlikely. (Stranger things have occurred, though, I s'pose.) He treated the business as it were his. Maaaaannnn... If I were in the restaurant/retail world this is exactly who I would want on my team. And it's probably who I would have leading the team. One thing I thought driving outta there was that this young guy could take that approach -- the approach of just being kind and professional -- and parlay that into being a multi-unit manager of something, anything, by probably age 25, because so few people in the retail/restaurant world are approaching their work with an attitude to do their best. (And, maybe, just maybe, it's because people are paid a wage that doesn't allow them to support themselves.) But, not this guy. This dude rocked and it's so rare to be treated this way in that environment that it's notable. (A sad commentary on our world.)

And the pie and sticks were awesome, but you already knew that Greeks makes a great pie so...

Very good food if you can find them open on the weekends. Friday and Saturday closes at 10 pm. Never seen that at a pizza joint! Pappas John's wins my business as I don't get back in town by 10 pm. How about a 11 or midnight? 4/11/25 Back in the area after 4 years and go to my favorite pizza place Greeks. Ordered my usual Greeks Special and know that what I ordered but when I got it home, it was the puke Garden Special vegetarian I suppose pizza. I called them about it and they offered to make it right. But when you’re hypoglycemic and need it now, you eat what’s there. Make sure you open the box while at the counter and make double sure you get what you ordered and paid for. I’m not a vegetarian and a...

Didn’t even want to leave a review because I like this place. Tried to use the contact us link on the website though, and that’s not working either 😑.

I paid extra to build a custom pizza, tipped when I got in the store, and then my pizza was wrong. Not even close.

Was supposed to be banana peppers, green peppers, jalapeño, onion, and parm/romano cheese. I got half pepp, half sausage, green peppers, and mushrooms.

So I spent $40 on my total order, paid an extra $2 for the custom pizza vs. the custom they gave me, tipped when I picked it up, and now I’m left unsatisfied.

Pretty disappointing from a place that is...