Mity Nice Cafe — Restaurant in Citrus Park

Hidden Gem Incoming!!! Check out the Facebook page Honest and Respectful Food Reviews of Hillsborough County Tampa Florida for more!

Mity Nice Cafe 5944 Benjamin Rd

Me: 8.5/10 Keegan: 8.0/10 Anna: 8.0/10

This place was absolutely delicious. Blink you will drive right by it. Thanks to Google for helping me track down this spot. They are more than just a sandwich shop but you all know once I spotted the Cuban it was on!

Hurricane - This is one of the best deli sandwiches I have found in Tampa so far. That's a massive statement from me as a great sandwich is one of my favorite things to eat. This was piled full of meats! The swiss and onions were such a nice compliment to the meat. The bacon was perfect. Let's not forget to mention it's served on Cuban bread! Oh, and it's under $9 bucks too, what a steal of a deal!

Cuban - Hello top 10 arrival. I need to evaluate my list but this will end up around 8 or so. It was an extremely balanced sandwich and that is always a win! Great pickles are always a plus too. The pork was very good but could have a touch more bang of flavor! Again, under $9 bucks for this huge sandwich.

They also fo breakfast, many other types of sandwiches, burgers (which I will try next) and even Cuban pizza! There is something for all!

Two extra notes on this spot. The home made coleslaw was a winner too! Lastly. Chef Joe was an absolutely outstanding face of this spot. He has passion for his food and love for for the customer. Great job!

Yall, this is one of those spots that I'm telling you to go try. It needs to be known and deserves your business. I won't make this statement unless it's really...

NEVER EVER AGAIN WILL I EAT HERE My coworker has been telling me for months about this restaurant and today I finally tried it which was a big mistake. I got the Italian sub and the meat wasn't fresh at all. I thought it would be deli sliced meat but it wasn't and the Cuban bread was stale. My coworker went to pick up the food. The sandwich was $6.49 and I got a 16.9 fl oz bottle of coke which the website lists as $2.25 I think they soda was part of a pack purchased from Sam's or Costco and I had no idea of the price that's way too much for a small bottle of coke. My total came to $8.74 and with tax should have been $9.40 but my card was charged $9.89. I know it's only a few cents more but what is the upcharge for? And to top it all off the sandwich made me sick. I will never go here again. Probably upcharge people like that all day every day. Imagine the extra money at the end...

If you’re looking for a true hidden gem in Tampa, Mity Nice Café is it. The vibe here is super laid-back and welcoming, like a spot you’d want to become your regular go-to.

The real standout for me is the Cuban breakfast food—it’s authentic, flavorful, and made with so much care. The Cuban toast is buttery and perfectly crisp, the café con leche is strong and smooth, and the breakfast plates are hearty without being overdone. You can tell everything is made fresh, and it tastes like the kind of meal you’d get in someone’s home kitchen.

The staff is always friendly and makes you feel right at home, which just adds to the whole experience. Whether you’re grabbing a quick coffee and toast on the way to work or sitting down for a full breakfast, this place never disappoints.

Honestly, Mity Nice Café deserves way more attention—it’s one of Tampa’s best little spots for a great...