Salvatore's Old Fashioned Pizzeria — Restaurant in City of Rochester

I'll start by saying I'm not the biggest fan of Salvatore's...they're usually my last choice for ordering pizza, to the point I'd rather get Little Ceasers pizza before ordering Salvatore's.

My friend lives right down the road from here, and I drive by here quite often and think to myself "If there's a shop called Donuts Delite, they probably have great donuts...I should stop sometime". I never did.

However last night after working in my friends studio for a bit we decided to get some food, and he suggested Salvatore's since it's right down the road. Even though I'm not the biggest fan of Salvatore's pizza (IMO quality is average and price is high given the quality) I'm always up for some pizza... so we decided to go there. Unknown to me we pull into Donuts Delite parking lot and a sense of confusion overwhelmed me. To my surprise and with much excitement I walk into a shop that sells donuts AND pizza! I had no idea the two establishments had joined forces, very cool!

This was around 7:30PM, and anytime I have visited any other Salvatore's the slice selection is lack luster even around lunch time. When I worked on the road and had minimal time to stop for lunch somewhere, Salvatore's was usually one of my last choices given my experiences with the lack of variety and high(ish) cost. This location though had a few fresh slice pies, and a good selection of semi-fresh looking specialty slices. Not only was the pizza selection good...they also had different varieties of stuffed breads, and different varieties of garlic knots! My mind was blown! Either the manager of this location loves variety, or the entire staff does...but either way this was my best experience with a Salvatore's location.

Fresh slice of pepperoni, garbage plate stuffed bread, and a couple donuts were my choices...and I was far from disappointed with my food.

Kudos guys, the team at this location knocked it out of the park! Keep up the great work, great variety, and great...

We've ordered many times from Salvatore's. Sometimes they're ON while other times they are OFF. When they're on, everything is amazing! When they're off, it's frustrating. In each of my off experiences, it's simply a matter of not following instructions on orders that I plugged in using their app. Tonight I ordered a steak sub with provolone, banana peppers, garlic spread. Normally I'd order it with steak sauce but the past few times it's been forgotten so I skipped it knowing I'd just be adding it once home. I ordered it as a warm sub, toasted and well done (crispy), and cut in 4. I got fresh bread, not toasted, cut in half. So I'm toasting it at home in my oven and adding my own steak sauce. It's very frustrating because I know how good the food can be as I've been very satisfied with it many times before. The inconsistency is why I give 3 stars. Give me consistency and I'll gladly give 5 stars every time.

The customer service in the shop is always great. We're always greeted with smiles and treated...

I work for a transportation company that is nearby, and we always order from this location; the food and service is  normally top notch.

Decided to order a slice of pizza for myself, boneless chix wings, and a dozen donuts.  I ordered way ahead of time (on-line) to do a pick-up.  The place was pretty busy so I was happy I ordered ahead of time.

Needless to say, order was not ready, waited over 1/2 hour.  I normally don't  complain, but when I got home the pizza was so oily, I soaked it up with 3 paper towels, the same with the boneless  chix. I took a bite of each, and threw in the garbage.

On a good note, the donuts were awesome, and the young lady out front was very nice, and apologetic.  Normally I'd leave a decent tip, but the wait was way too long, especially when I saw others coming in AFTER me being served rather quickly, and some had pre-ordered as well.

Once is enough for me, and  I'll unlikely  order for my company again anytime soon; hopefully things will...