Anthony's Pizza & Pasta — Restaurant in Colorado

My boyfriend and I ordered Anthony's pizza last night. Extra large Pepperoni pizza, bread sticks, and 2 cheesecakes. We submitted our order at 6:36pm. Order time was about 45 minutes. Okay. 7:30pm rolls around still no pizza. My Boyfriend gives them a call, they say the pizza is on the make table about to be made, they have had a busy night. Understandable being im a Sous Chef myself and can understand how crazy busy nights can be. 8:10pm rolls around, STILL NO PIZZA. My boyfriend gives them a call again.. still working on our pizza, we try to stay calm and agree with proceeding with our order. 9:15 rolls around and the door bell rings... took 2 1/2 hours to get our pizza ... wasn't even what we ordered. They brought a banana pepper pizza.. not our pepperoni pizza. Cheese sticks not bread stick. But we actually got our cheesecake. It was cold and NOT good. WE WILL NOT BE ORDERING ANTHONYS PIZZA EVER AGAIN. Highly disappointed 😞 not worth the...

Edited from original review: Been here two times within the last few months and, something changed here recently and not for the better.

Both the food and the service is no where near as good as it was for the last several years.

Pizza sauce seemed watery and lacked flavor. Almost like it was frozen/thawed out or simply past its prime. The crust was ok but seems like the oven isn’t cleaned enough as the bottom side had a bad taste to it. The cheese also tastes cheap as well. I had some severe stomach pains from eating here yesterday and won’t be coming back here until both the quality of food and quality returns to my original visit over 4 years ago.

Original: Been looking for a good NY pizza place for a while now. This is the closest thing out here, the hardest part is the water for the sauce/dough. But the thin crust pizza...

Please know, I’ve never left a one star review before, nor a bad review, but I feel this one is important. This is the most over priced pizza I’ve ever encountered. All I can say is it’s pizza. It’s not exceptional pizza. 20$ for a small cheese pizza and 2$/ topping after? Really? I hope you don’t like any vegetables on your pizza. Even by the slice you pay an additional 1$/topping. Get over yourselves. I’d rather order dominos and sacrifice quality instead of feeling assaulted. Yes, everybody has raised their prices, but you are taking FULL advantage. It’s ridiculous. And the reviews are telling. As residents of CPV, we will not support your...