Tony's Pizza — Restaurant in Columbus

My boyfriend lived in Italy for 25 years and is always looking for the perfect thin crust pizza. I remembered seeing signs for this new place and decided to give it a try after seeing the pictures on here.

The price is the good. 17.50 for large extra cheese. Only 15 without extra cheese.

I went inside to pick it up and the teenager boy was friendly.

There are tables and chairs inside to dine in, however it wasn't very welcoming. The kid was assembling pizza boxes on one table and the other table was filled with random personal belongings. So, even if I wanted to eat inside, there was nowhere for me to sit.

The crust is perfect. Will definitely come back to try more and hopefully one day be able to eat inside.

Edit: I tried the spaghetti dinner. A huge portion of pasta with marinara, melted mozzarella, 2 garlic knots and a nice salad with homemade dressing...

I had an absolutely fantastic experience at Tony’s Pizza on 946 Galloway Rd, Galloway, OH 43119! This family-owned gem truly made me feel like part of their family from the moment I walked in. I ordered two burgers and mozzarella sticks, and everything was beyond delicious—the mozzarella sticks had an incredible cheese pull that was just perfection! The burgers were cooked to juicy, flavorful goodness, and the quality was top-notch. To top it off, I got two sodas, and they even threw in an extra one for free, which was such a kind gesture. The price was unbeatable for the quality and portion size, making it an incredible value. The warm, welcoming atmosphere and friendly service made the whole experience unforgettable. I’m already looking forward to my next visit—Tony’s Pizza has earned a loyal customer in me! Five stars...

Everyone needs to try this place! Full disclosure: I've never eaten pizza in New York. But I have eaten pizza probably a thousand times in my life, and this is near the top of all of the pizzas I've ever had. Thin but still crispy crust; almost over-loaded with toppings, on top of a perfect amount of cheese and an absolutely delicious sauce. They do this style of pizza better than anyone else in the area I've ever had. The pizza's awesome, but the Stromboli might be even better. It's like their pizza, folded over, with even more garlic. And their garlic bread is good too. But if you order it, spring for the cheese. This place is so good, that we've ordered from there as least once a week every week since they've opened. You will not be...