Gallery Pizza — Restaurant in Delaware

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ A Taste of NYC Right Here in Delaware!

Gallery Pizza at 1622 W Newport Pike, Wilmington, DE, is an absolute gem for pizza lovers. As a proud New Yorker who grew up on classic Bronx-style slices, I can confidently say this is the closest I’ve come to tasting home outside of the city.

I ordered their large cheese pizza, and it was perfection from start to finish. The crust strikes the ideal balance—crispy on the outside with a soft, airy interior. The cheese? Melted to perfection with just the right stretch, rich flavor, and an excellent salt balance. Their sauce is the real deal, a perfect blend of sweet and tangy with fresh herbs shining through.

Even better, the pizza has the perfect “NYC flop”—it folds beautifully without losing its structure, and every bite delivers that nostalgic, authentic flavor we all crave. I also tried their sausage, which was juicy, well-seasoned, and evenly distributed, adding depth to an already amazing pie.

Gallery Pizza stands out not only for its taste but also for its value. Finding pizza of this quality at such an affordable price is rare. For anyone in the Wilmington area—whether you're a Delaware local or a homesick New Yorker—this place is a must-visit.

If you’re looking for authentic NY-style pizza with a perfect crust, flavorful sauce, and premium toppings, Gallery Pizza delivers every time. This is easily a 9/10 pizza experience. They’ve earned a lifelong customer in me.

📍 Gallery Pizza 1622 W Newport Pike Wilmington, DE 19804

Don’t walk—run to this spot. It’s the best slice you’ll find outside of New York City! 🍕

Edit: Cannoli Review

I also had the pleasure of trying Gallery Pizza’s cannoli, and it did not disappoint! The filling had a wonderfully smooth and creamy consistency, with just the right level of sweetness that balanced perfectly with the crispy shell. While it had slightly fewer chocolate chips than I usually prefer, the overall flavor and texture were spot-on.

The attention to detail in their dessert matches the quality of their pizza. It’s clear that Gallery Pizza takes pride in everything they make. Whether you’re stopping by for a slice or looking for a sweet treat to finish off your meal, their cannoli is a must-try.

Highly...

I hate to leave this place a bad review, I really do, because their pizza is really good. But I just ordered an Italian Stromboli and the ham inside of it smelled rotten. It smelled like it was bad and it tasted bad. I mean it actually tasted like it was tainted. It tasted like the compressor in the refrigerator was broken and leaking water on it. It had an awful taste to it and it completely ruined the entire Stromboli. If I didn’t have to fight so much traffic due to road construction and rush-hour I would’ve taken it back. It’s a shame because pizza is about the only thing that they make good at this place and I no longer will even be getting that because sooner or later The low quality of the Stromboli will eventually trickle down to the pizza as well. I personally don’t have money to waste like that. This was supposed to be dinner for a family and I had to throw that slop away. It was absolutely lousy ! You might want to get a hold on this problem because somebody’s gonna end up getting sick from it or have a stroke because of how...

I had purchased pizza several times with good experiences.

The last time was a couple months ago and the pizza was just bad. Didn't taste like the previous pizzas had at this location.

I called and spoke with who I believe was the manager at the time. She was the only female working whenever I'd gone in. I explained I was dissatisfied and that due to the amount of salt on the pizza wasn't able to eat it. She was very rude but told me next time I was up they'd replace it, then hung up on me.

Today I went in and the gentleman who makes the pizza told me she wasn't there anymore and if I wanted a pizza I'd pay for it.

Fair, I'm going down the street to Doms where I always...