Pizza on Main — Restaurant in East Hampton

So our two kids were in the mood for a pizza. being excited to see a new small business come in we decided to give them a try because we heard their pizza tastes really good. So I called up and asked for a small cheese with half pepperoni for takeout. They said they won’t split toppings on a small pizza. So I decided to go in person to them and place the order because maybe the person on the phone misunderstood me. So I spoke with the people behind the counter and mentioned I only wanted a small cheese pizza with half pepperoni. They still said im sorry we don’t do that with small pizzas. Last time asking “ so you mean to tell me you can’t put a couple of slices on one half of the pizza for me and they still wouldn’t do it. The next size up available is large and no medium. Which is too much for the kids. I did mention that I was a first time customer and I was pretty disappointed on how this turned out. So I left and went to my usual pizzeria and they made a small cheese/pepperoni no problem. Won’t...

Update experience at Mateos Taco's: The pork carnita tacos three pack at $20 my first time was fairly tasty and fair portion. I went back three more times and had various experiences with the tacos as the pork was more of a pulled pork instead of what you typically get in a street taco it was very salty. Also the meat was very wet and all my tacos fell apart on the first bite because they were so saturated. The beef street tacos were also very salty. The chicken empenadas are good but i dont think theyre made on premises. It's frustrating as you want this place to do well but I just don't see it. In total I gave them my business on 4 occasions and I think I'm done. I hope they improve truthfully.

Ordered a large pizza with pepperoni and onions. It was inedible, salty with a vinegar after taste. Really disappointed wanted it to be good as a local. Pizza was also very expensive at $38. Can't have bad pizza for that price point hope to see the quality turned around and would like to give another shot when...

Came in after a long bike ride. Walked in to what I thought was a counter or host. A gentleman behind the counter said I could sit where ever I like and he called me Boss. I hate that! In fact he called everyone Boss even while on the phone taking orders. I had to get a menu myself. After what seems to be 10min the same gentleman ask me if I wanted something to drink. I ordered a club soda. He had to check if they had it. That seemed odd. Then a nice young lady server brought me my drink. I then ordered a meatball appetizer and a 10” cheese pizza and asked if they could be brought out at the same time. The meatballs came out in like 1 min. The pizza then followed in a reasonable amount of time. I took one look at the pizza and I could swear it was a frozen pizza it did not look like it was freshly made. I was very hungry so I ate it. I would say that Amy’s frozen pizza is better. Strange...