P&J Pizza- Elizabethtown — Restaurant in Elizabethtown

After reading over Google's recommendations for restaurants nearby I settled on P & J Pizza. The parking's in a little one way side lot, so when you exit you're going to be taking a back road to get out; beware in the dark if you're unfamiliar with the area, as I was.

The guy working the counter was also preparing pizzas so he was understandably busy, though he was still patient and answered my questions as I took my time looking over the menu.

I ordered the mild buffalo boneless wings and the loaded fries, both of which were hot and fresh even by the time I made it home. I was thoroughly impressed with the 'fancy' aluminum container the fries were in, as it kept them warmer than any styrofoam container would've. The wings were fine, I mean, they're boneless wings at a small pizza restaurant- they're not exactly crafted from the finest meat, but by all means I enjoyed eating them. The same goes for the loaded fries as well, it was great that they managed to make it all the way home without getting soggy from the cheese.

All in all, it was a good choice for a late...

I want to give them a good review really, but I just can't. The pizza is good but their service is terrible.

Several times I've ordered, showed up to get my pizza, and been told it'll be out in a minute. I'll then watch them bring out several orders, never once checking to see if any of them them are for the people waiting in the restaurant.

You have to literally ask "is that my order?" every time they pull something out of the oven

My wife just picked up a order from them. She came in, gave them her order number and they said it'll be out in a minute. She sat there for twenty minutes directly in front of the counter before she could get someone's attention, only to find that the pizza had been sitting on top of the oven nearly the whole time.

The guy at the counter didn't even apologize He just said "what, it's still hot!"

No. No it was not still hot. It was warm If the top of the oven kept pizzas hot, you'd be able to cook them there.

Oh, and who runs a business but can't be bothered to have an up-to-date menu on line? It's 2018. ...

We have been to P&J's many times since moving to Elizabethtown 10 years ago. We instantly fell in love with their Stromboli. Over the years we have had times when the customer service was poor; however, I don't recall a time we have ever been disappointed with their food. In the past several weeks I have had trouble getting ahold of them to call in an order. Today I tried to call in an order, expecting maybe I wouldn't be able to get through, but I was pleasantly surprised to have gotten through and had a very good customer service experience. Our food was done on time and absolutely perfect. It is the best Stromboli I have had from any pizza place. I'm so very happy with P&J's and after 10 years still am amazed when I tasted how good their Stromboli is. The dough is extraordinary and whatever ingredients they use are all-around incredible. Thank you!!! Keep up...