HTML SitemapExplore
logo
Find Things to DoFind The Best Restaurants

Stromboli's New York Pizzeria — Restaurant in Florida

Name
Stromboli's New York Pizzeria
Description
New York-style pies, spaghetti & other Italian fare at a laid-back pizzeria with table seating.
Nearby attractions
Lake Smith
Horizon West, FL 34786
Nearby restaurants
Bella Tuscany
13424 Summerport Village Pkwy, Windermere, FL 34786
Summer Palace Restaurant
13428 Summerport Village Pkwy, Windermere, FL 34786
Agave Azul Windermere
5855 Winter Garden Vineland Rd Suite 100, Windermere, FL 34786
Josie's Pizza & Wings-Windermere
5855 Winter Garden Vineland Rd Suite #150, Windermere, FL 34786
Chi-kin
5845 Winter Garden Vineland Rd Suite 100, Windermere, FL 34786
Bruster's Real Ice Cream
5855 Winter Garden Vineland Rd Ste 110, Windermere, FL 34786
Loop Cafe
Windermere, FL 34786
Henko Cafe
13790 Bridgewater Crossings Blvd #1000, Windermere, FL 34786
Nearby hotels
Amazing Vacation Homes Florida
13790 Bridgewater Crossings Blvd #1080, Windermere, FL 34786
Related posts
Keywords
Stromboli's New York Pizzeria tourism.Stromboli's New York Pizzeria hotels.Stromboli's New York Pizzeria bed and breakfast. flights to Stromboli's New York Pizzeria.Stromboli's New York Pizzeria attractions.Stromboli's New York Pizzeria restaurants.Stromboli's New York Pizzeria travel.Stromboli's New York Pizzeria travel guide.Stromboli's New York Pizzeria travel blog.Stromboli's New York Pizzeria pictures.Stromboli's New York Pizzeria photos.Stromboli's New York Pizzeria travel tips.Stromboli's New York Pizzeria maps.Stromboli's New York Pizzeria things to do.
Stromboli's New York Pizzeria things to do, attractions, restaurants, events info and trip planning
Stromboli's New York Pizzeria
United StatesFloridaStromboli's New York Pizzeria

Basic Info

Stromboli's New York Pizzeria

13518 Summerport Village Pkwy, Windermere, FL 34786
4.0(264)
order
Order
delivery
Save
spot

Ratings & Description

Info

New York-style pies, spaghetti & other Italian fare at a laid-back pizzeria with table seating.

attractions: Lake Smith, restaurants: Bella Tuscany, Summer Palace Restaurant, Agave Azul Windermere, Josie's Pizza & Wings-Windermere, Chi-kin, Bruster's Real Ice Cream, Loop Cafe, Henko Cafe
logoLearn more insights from Wanderboat AI.
Phone
(407) 654-5291
Website
strombolisnypizzeria.com

Plan your stay

hotel
Pet-friendly Hotels in Florida
Find a cozy hotel nearby and make it a full experience.
hotel
Affordable Hotels in Florida
Find a cozy hotel nearby and make it a full experience.
hotel
The Coolest Hotels You Haven't Heard Of (Yet)
Find a cozy hotel nearby and make it a full experience.
hotel
Trending Stays Worth the Hype in Florida
Find a cozy hotel nearby and make it a full experience.

Featured dishes

View full menu
dish
Personal Feast
dish
Wings
dish
Philly Cheesesteak
dish
Pizza Bruschetta
dish
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
dish
Hangover Pizza
dish
Pizza Viagra
dish
NY Pizza House
dish
Aloha
dish
The Butcher's Block
dish
Margherita
dish
Bianca 3 Cheese
dish
BBQ Hawaiian Chicken
dish
Primavera
dish
Chicken Cutlet Parmigiana Alla Vodka Sauce Sub
dish
Eggplant Parmigiana Sub
dish
Sausage, Peppers & Onion Sub
dish
Italian Sausage Parmigiana Sub
dish
Hangover Hero/ Sub
dish
Meatball Parmigiana Sub
dish
Chicken Cutlet Parmigiana Sub
dish
Philly Cheesesteak
dish
Large Sicilian Cannoli
dish
NY Thin Cheese (X Large 18" 8 Slices)
dish
Thick Sicilian (Thick Square 14")
dish
NY Thin Cheese (Large 14" 6 Slices)
dish
NY Thin Cheese (10" Personal)
dish
Grilled Chicken Salad
dish
Greek Salad
dish
Caprese
dish
Grilled Chicken Caesar
dish
House Salad
dish
Friday Pizza And Wings Combo Special
dish
Saturday Stromboli Special
dish
Wednesday 20 Wings Special
dish
Wednesday 10 Wings Special
dish
Sunday Sandwich Combo Special
dish
Tuesday 10" Special
dish
Traditional Stromboli
dish
Create Your Own
dish
Ravioli
dish
Spaghetti
dish
Penne
dish
Calzone
dish
Fried Cheese Ravioli (8)
dish
Garlic Rolls (9)
dish
Fried Mozzarella
dish
Garlic Rolls (3)
dish
Side Of Hangover AKA Vodka Sauce
dish
Chicken Tenders
dish
Garlic Bread With Cheese
dish
Garlic Bread
dish
Garlic Puffies (1 Dozen)
dish
Fried Zucchini
dish
Penne Alla Hangover

Reviews

Nearby attractions of Stromboli's New York Pizzeria

Lake Smith

Lake Smith

Lake Smith

5.0

(1)

Open 24 hours
Click for details

Things to do nearby

Paint sneakers in a shaded courtyard
Paint sneakers in a shaded courtyard
Wed, Dec 17 • 5:00 PM
Kissimmee, Florida, 34747
View details
Kayak through Winter Park lakes in Florida
Kayak through Winter Park lakes in Florida
Mon, Dec 15 • 8:00 AM
Winter Park, Florida, 32789
View details
Paddleboard the scenic Winter Park Chain of Lakes
Paddleboard the scenic Winter Park Chain of Lakes
Sun, Dec 14 • 4:30 PM
Winter Park, Florida, 32789, United States
View details

Nearby restaurants of Stromboli's New York Pizzeria

Bella Tuscany

Summer Palace Restaurant

Agave Azul Windermere

Josie's Pizza & Wings-Windermere

Chi-kin

Bruster's Real Ice Cream

Loop Cafe

Henko Cafe

Bella Tuscany

Bella Tuscany

4.4

(700)

Click for details
Summer Palace Restaurant

Summer Palace Restaurant

3.6

(194)

Click for details
Agave Azul Windermere

Agave Azul Windermere

4.7

(1.9K)

Click for details
Josie's Pizza & Wings-Windermere

Josie's Pizza & Wings-Windermere

4.4

(154)

$

Click for details
Get the Appoverlay
Get the AppOne tap to find yournext favorite spots!
Wanderboat LogoWanderboat

Your everyday Al companion for getaway ideas

CompanyAbout Us
InformationAI Trip PlannerSitemap
SocialXInstagramTiktokLinkedin
LegalTerms of ServicePrivacy Policy

Get the app

© 2025 Wanderboat. All rights reserved.
logo

Posts

Mark J. HornMark J. Horn
12/21/2023 called in a carry-out order for an 18” cheese pizza with LIGHT pizza sauce and garlic rolls. Got the pizza home and of course, not right. There’s literally NO sauce on the pizza. It’s cheese bread. Amazing. Is it really that difficult to get it right? I’ve never worked in the food industry, but I sure bet I could figure “light pizza sauce” out. It’s just slightly less than what you’d normally slather on the crust. Not hard people! 6/06/2025-Another visit for carry-out. Seems every time I ask for light sauce, it comes with ZERO sauce. I asked for a tad more well done, the bottom of the crust was BLACK, charred. The pizza was disgusting. It seems if I so much as ask for things beyond just saying “xl pepperoni pizza” they’ll deliberately screw the pie up. I’ve just given up on this crappy place.
Doug StroudDoug Stroud
A very nice family run pizza place! I had one of their daily specials which consisted of two slices with one topping and a fountain drink, I opted for bottled water. The pizza was quick fresh and delicious and they even had some Mikes hot honey to add to the slices! You could tell the family that makes pizzas together stays together. There was a very nice, polite young man who was attending the customers and taking the orders. The family who appeared to be maybe a dad or granddad who was the master craftsman, then his kids or grandkids were helping in the back! Anyways very nice to see and the food was awesome, the place was clean. Only thing is curb appeal as it is located in the strip area of cornerstone and they have a sign missing, but don’t let that detour you it was great!
CathyCathy
Very sad to write this bad review because Stramboli's used to be the best family owned pizzeria in the area . Now there's a new owner and it's terrible Eggplant Parmesan and Chicken Parmesan was awful. The manager Miguel didn't even have the courtesy to apologize or make the situation better instead he seemed upset and had a nasty attitude towards me. I have not yet tried the pizza recently but now I'm afraid to go there. Just look at the pictures and judge for yourself. I placed the order and went to pick-up myself and when I got there they said that it just came out of the oven, to my surprise the containers were cold and when I got home everything was dry/cold and it only took me 5 minutes to get home.
See more posts
See more posts
hotel
Find your stay

Pet-friendly Hotels in Florida

Find a cozy hotel nearby and make it a full experience.

12/21/2023 called in a carry-out order for an 18” cheese pizza with LIGHT pizza sauce and garlic rolls. Got the pizza home and of course, not right. There’s literally NO sauce on the pizza. It’s cheese bread. Amazing. Is it really that difficult to get it right? I’ve never worked in the food industry, but I sure bet I could figure “light pizza sauce” out. It’s just slightly less than what you’d normally slather on the crust. Not hard people! 6/06/2025-Another visit for carry-out. Seems every time I ask for light sauce, it comes with ZERO sauce. I asked for a tad more well done, the bottom of the crust was BLACK, charred. The pizza was disgusting. It seems if I so much as ask for things beyond just saying “xl pepperoni pizza” they’ll deliberately screw the pie up. I’ve just given up on this crappy place.
Mark J. Horn

Mark J. Horn

hotel
Find your stay

Affordable Hotels in Florida

Find a cozy hotel nearby and make it a full experience.

Get the Appoverlay
Get the AppOne tap to find yournext favorite spots!
A very nice family run pizza place! I had one of their daily specials which consisted of two slices with one topping and a fountain drink, I opted for bottled water. The pizza was quick fresh and delicious and they even had some Mikes hot honey to add to the slices! You could tell the family that makes pizzas together stays together. There was a very nice, polite young man who was attending the customers and taking the orders. The family who appeared to be maybe a dad or granddad who was the master craftsman, then his kids or grandkids were helping in the back! Anyways very nice to see and the food was awesome, the place was clean. Only thing is curb appeal as it is located in the strip area of cornerstone and they have a sign missing, but don’t let that detour you it was great!
Doug Stroud

Doug Stroud

hotel
Find your stay

The Coolest Hotels You Haven't Heard Of (Yet)

Find a cozy hotel nearby and make it a full experience.

hotel
Find your stay

Trending Stays Worth the Hype in Florida

Find a cozy hotel nearby and make it a full experience.

Very sad to write this bad review because Stramboli's used to be the best family owned pizzeria in the area . Now there's a new owner and it's terrible Eggplant Parmesan and Chicken Parmesan was awful. The manager Miguel didn't even have the courtesy to apologize or make the situation better instead he seemed upset and had a nasty attitude towards me. I have not yet tried the pizza recently but now I'm afraid to go there. Just look at the pictures and judge for yourself. I placed the order and went to pick-up myself and when I got there they said that it just came out of the oven, to my surprise the containers were cold and when I got home everything was dry/cold and it only took me 5 minutes to get home.
Cathy

Cathy

See more posts
See more posts

Reviews of Stromboli's New York Pizzeria

4.0
(264)
avatar
1.0
1y

me and my friend just left this place. we stopped by because we were starving and couldn’t wait until we got home to eat. everything was pleasant at first… until we had to wait for my friend’s order. it took a reasonable amount of time for my two slices, but we were waiting there almost 20-25 minutes for the second order of two slices. not to mention, while we were waiting for my friend’s order, the owner (it seems, it was hard to tell based off of his unprofessional behavior) decided it would be a good idea to berate a minor that he was letting go in the main eating area. not only was he being rude to the minor, but he was arguing back and forth with him about hours he had worked and wages he was owed- and ended up paying him the rest of what he was owed cash right there, and told him that he was actually giving him more than he should so he should be “grateful”. it was absolutely disgusting behavior, and a gross business practice. it severely disappointed me. and so did the pizza. it wasn’t even worth the wait, and it lacked flavor, and it was very greasy. i wouldn’t come back here and i would not recommend it.

edit after seeing owner’s response: i knew the person you were berating in the middle of the dining room was a minor because i spoke to him outside after i left. i talked to hin because the way you spoke to him and treated him made me so angry for him, and i wanted to make sure he was okay. it was at that point he said that he’s used to this kind of behavior, because he’s only 16 and still a minor. i don’t have to know all the facts of the situation or see his timesheet, like you demanded from him, to know that the way you spoke to him about the matter was unprofessional. you interrupted him multiple times, didn’t even look him in the eye half the time you were talking to him, and didn’t even have the decency to have the conversation in private. not only this, but you didn’t even want to listen to him, and when you figured out he was right, you decided to pay him the rest of what he was owed cash, and told him that he should be grateful for this actually because you didn’t take any taxes out. again, this is a 16 year old kid. what the hell is he going to know about taxes? watching that entire exchange really turned my opinion about this place 180, and seeing the owner’s response to my review only affirms my decision to never go back again. besides, their food isn’t even good. as i said in my...

   Read more
avatar
1.0
9y

RUDE!

I USED to frequent Stromboli's a lot, but not after what happened in the parking lot the other evening.

The restaurant is located in a plaza with several other businesses, including a large grocery store (Publix). I live in the area but was caught in traffic and had a phone meeting with a client scheduled. I pulled into the plaza parking lot to make the call, rather than driving while talking on my cell phone. I parked in the parking lot (which I have done many times before since I buy my groceries and other services there) and started my call.

In the middle of my call with my client, the delivery driver from Stromboli's came to my car and interrupted my call to ask me what I was doing there. (In a public parking lot where there are multiple businesses). I told him that obviously I was talking on the phone. He was very rude.

I kept speaking with my client and did not move. After a few minutes, the Stromboli's employee came back and interrupted my call again to ask me what I was doing. I was holding the phone to my ear, so it was obvious that I was speaking on the phone. This time (with my client listening) he told me to leave. "People don't just sit in their cars and make phone calls. Leave!" Again I reiterated to him that it was a public parking lot that serviced multiple businesses. "GO HOME" he yelled at me ... while I was on the phone. My client was astonished at his behavior. Then he threatened to call the police ... to which I told him to go ahead because I am certain that sitting in your car in a parking lot is not against the law. He sped off in his car. I finished my call, no police showed up ... then I went home.

If this is the caliber of individual that Stromboli's thinks should be part of it's "team" then I am pretty sure I don't want to see what they are doing in the kitchen.

Note: I have lived in the area for almost 20 years, own a professional services business, and drive a nice high end SUV. There was nothing about my vehicle or appearance that caused his...

   Read more
avatar
2.0
3y

We have been ordering from here for years and since the new owners took over it has been nothing but growing disappointment. Slow service and poor service have become the norm. Today may be the final straw. I placed an order at 5pm and was told it would be 45-50 minutes for pickup. A little long but it’s New Year’s Eve and I figured I’d be home with it by 6. I walk in at 545 and am told oh your early and it will be another 25 minutes?!?! I explained I was right on time actually. She looks at her screen and confirms oh I guess you are. I am told well we are behind and there are 5 pizzas ahead of your to go into the oven so it’s at least another 25 minutes. No I’m sorry. I asked that since I was here could they put my pizza in ahead of anyone that was not already here waiting…. instead I am offered the opportunity to cancel which I honestly think they wanted me to do as it may have helped them get less behind. At this point I am committed and decide to wait it out with the 8 other people who are waiting in the dining area after being told their pizza is not ready. I think one of my New Years resolutions may be to find a new pizza place. It’s a shame because we always have enjoyed this place under the previous owner but it’s becoming more disappointing with every order and the new owner does not seem to care. If you have all night to wait for a pizza then this is the place to order from. 615 and my pizza is done. They call my name toss it on the counter and walk away with not even a thank you. All I can say is thanks for helping me follow through on this resolution....

   Read more
Page 1 of 7
Previous
Next