Blue Heaven Ice Cream — Restaurant in Fontana-on-Geneva Lake

Edited as of June 2025: First, I still love Chocolate Shoppe Ice Cream flavors. But ever since there has been a change in ownership at Blue Heaven, I have noticed a price increase and decrease in serving size. For a single scoop in a cup it is $6! So for my husband and I, it was $12 for two small cups of ice cream. It is quite expensive for a small amount of ice cream especially when the scoop size is notably smaller compared to previous ownership. I get that everything is more expensive now and businesses need to make a profit but this seems rather inflated especially when I can go to Daniels and get a gallon of Tillamook ice cream for $8/$9. I want to support my local folks and businesses around here but it sometimes feels like prices are geared towards making the maximum amount from tourists and it’s your locals who will really be there for...

We were staying at the Abbey and asked about a place nearby for ice cream. They referred us to Blue Heaven and we walked over. Oh My God. They have a selection of unusual cones—I had salty pretzel and my husband had chocolate. I never get cones, due to calories, but I had to experience this. I had some type of coffee ice cream with dark chocolate with a scoop of something else, also with chocolate chips. It was divine with the salty cone. My husband had butter pecan and pistachio nut with the chocolate cone. Perfection. There is a small patio and we sat there under an umbrella and savored the...

My husband and I recently hired the Blue Heaven team for dessert at our wedding in Fontana. We aren't big cake people and wanted to do something a little different and fun! The owner, John, was super organized leading up to the event and even had us come into the shop for a tasting to pick out flavors and toppings which we loved!! A nice bonus was that they had a few non-dairy ice cream flavors and sorbet options to choose from for guests that might have dietary restrictions. We got a ton of compliments from our guests on the ice cream and...