B-Sides Pints and Pies — Restaurant in Greencastle

B-sides has its own entrance from the street but technically it's in the same building as BStreet. Anyone who's local to the area knows this used to be a restaurant by the name of Antrim House. My first observation is their "to go" layout. They have warmers by the door which makes it very quick and easy get your food on the way by. I've haven't done pick up yet so I'm not 100% sure how the process works. I'm assuming you can pay over the phone with a credit card so you don't have to go to the register. As far as the inside goes there are lots of movie posters and three TVs showing movies while you eat. The layout is really cool and they have plenty of seating for larger parties. They have a menu sitting inside on a stand that you use to figure out what you want then you go up and order at the register and pay. They hand you a beeper and then you seat yourself. Once your beeper goes off head up to the counter where they will have your pizza ready. They have 13 regular pizzas and usually a special one that changes periodically. My family of four ordered the #2-Pepperoni, #7 -Cheesesteak, and #9-Pork BBQ. With water to drink our total bill was $36 so each of us ate for less than $10 which is very rare these days. The pizzas are on the thinner side which I am fine with but the toppings could have been a little more generous. However, they were all very well flavored. I also have gotten to try #8-East meets West. It's not your typical Hawaiian because the ham is black forest and had a smoky flavor to it but it was very good. There were two people working register and one bartender who were all very nice and did a great job. No loud music and the TVs weren't turned up so it was not difficult to have a conversation with your table. Everything here was self-serve so you get your refills of water or soda as well as your own napkins and utensils if you need them and you also got your own parmesan cheese or red pepper flakes which are near the registers. Currently they do not have a website or phone number that I know of. I only found out about them because of Facebook. Overall I highly recommend this restaurant especially if you view Pizza as something more than just to stuff your...

A true NYC/New Haven pizza, unlike all those around who have average PA pizza who claim to be NY pizza. This is very thin, well done crust, and small amounts of cheese and sauce. Exactly how pizza should be. Maybe I'd want a tad more sauce here, other than that it was great. 9.1/10, which is insanely good.

Average Central PA pizzas are like 6-7.5/10 at best. Rosalie's would be the closest alternative, but it's nice not having to travel 20 minutes for great pizza. They're a different style that locals may be more used to. Thanks for doing the pizza the right away despite hesitance from locals at first how the well done crust is burnt (which it isn't, it's how pizza is supposed to come), or that it doesn't have loads of cheese. They're used to American-style pizza that's too thick and more about quantity than quality. If you look at the all-time greats that have been around forever like John's of Bleeker in NYC, this is what they look like. I never thought I'd see the day pizza like this can be found in Greencastle! It's the best I've had in PA, and honestly probably equally as good as the greats of NYC. Definitely better than Joe's, very similar to John's of Bleeker as mentioned.

The wings are also spectacular, though ideally I'd want 8-9 for $12, not 7. Maybe even a wing special? You have the important part down. Maybe add a couple more sauces that people are...

Was excited to check out this place as we were in Greencastle for something else. The menu is not overly large, but there are some unique items on there. I was not a huge fan of the pizza, it just didn't have a lot of flavor. It is a wood fired pizza oven, so if that is your thing, give it a shot. They have an okay selection of beers/wines to choose from. Sadly they were out of the cider that I wanted. I did get a pretty tasty sour though. The service was average, would have been nice to get a little more attention since it wasn't busy. I can't say much for the atmosphere since it was early in the day, but it is a pretty cool layout. I would recommend trying, but I don't know if I will...