Casa Agave Mexican Restaurant — Restaurant in Greencastle

Absolutely fantastic. From the food to the service to the atmosphere....FANTASTIC! There were 4 in our party and we started out by splitting the Seafood Molcajete...a steaming cauldron of seafood yumminess with cheese melted on top. We were in it to win it so, I got the Pollo Special (substituted queso sauce for the chipotle sauce) and my wife ordered the Chicken Fajita Salad. Both were absolutely delicious. I am always skeptical about grilled shrimp as they can be over-done and rubbery.....NOT SO...the shrimp and chicken were grilled to perfection! We were going for gold, so, we had to round out our meal and waistlines with fried ice cream. Our server was a polite young man, attentive to our needs and pleasant. All in all a wonderful dining experience and we will definitely be back! Stop in and check the place out!

Oh and my wife wanted me to let all the ladies out there know that their restrooms were spotlessly clean and fresh. Another...

Went with my daughter and the food was delicious but I question that it's authentic. I had the Birria Taco's and cheese was an added option for a few, the shells didn't seem to be dipped in the soupa grease and fried and it was served in some silver rack thingy that was really a waste of time and space. Now, that said authentic or not they offered a dish called Queso Fundido that was absolutely amazing!!!!! Not sure what kind of cheese they use, but I believe th e meet is Chorizo but I could definitely be wrong. I would return and order the Queso Fundido and order nothing else and the trip would be well worth it! Atmosphere was really laid back, waitress was definitely very friendly and not pushy. She even had a side conversation with my daughter about protein powders.

Again not really authentic but the spin they have in their dishes make it a worthwhile place to stop and I will be a return...

Let me start off by saying the food is amazing. Everything we ordered was outstanding and we will be back. They had me hooked on hot chips and fresh salsa.

I called in a large to-go order for our family of six and when I got home we noticed my meal was missing, the carnitas. Called in and explained the situation and without hesitation they said that they could refund me or replace the order. I chose for them to remake the meal. Picked it up and when I brought it home they had left me a special gift. Some of the best Tres Leches Cake I've ever tasted. They went above and beyond for their mistake and I greatly appreciate that.

Good food, good atmosphere, good people.

Food we recommend: Carnitas - super tender and delicious Steak Fajitas - Huge portions. LOTS of steak. Taco Salad Bowl - My 8 year old inhaled it. That's a...