Catanzareti Pizza — Restaurant in Lambertville

Stopped here on a whim. Large pie to go, peppers and onion. Awesome tasting pizza pie with generous toppings that were fresh. Ordered the pie and waited in the car. Thunderstorm broke out. Pouring... Gentleman behind the counter saw me getting out of my car and came to the shop door to indicate that I should wait and he would deliver our pie to car. I declined his offer but, really, this level of service for an order less than $20.00? Where do you see that anymore? We consider ourselves pizza snobs from New York City. This is only the second pizzeria to pass muster in 15 years of living in New Jersey and we will be regular customers going forward. Thank you, Catanzareti...

We drive thru lambertville on the way to the Poconos almost once a month. We stopped at a little place a few weeks ago and paid an insane price for a single size pizza that was ok at best. Tonight we stopped her and paid a little over $13 for a large cheese pizza that was Ahhhhmazing. Best pizza We have in years. Delicious crust, tasty sauce and perfect cheese. Cooked perfectly. This is now going to be our midway stop and two pizzas to go. Will need to come back to try their other dishes too. That sauce would be good on anything. Quite...

It’s a family owned biz so the staff are often preoccupied with arguing behind the counter, but it’s not loud or anything. It just sometimes feels like I’m interrupting them to place my order, which can be uncomfortable. But they’re friendly enough. And it’s just a very bare bones, functional sit-down place with six hard melamine booths up front, so don’t expect much in comfort there, either. But this is my favorite pizza on the planet, and neither of those other things really matter as long as I can...