Circle Pizza — Restaurant in Madison

ITALIAN COMBO. Oil & vinegar, mayo (yes do both), lettuce, cucumber, couple jalapeños, cheese, toasted.

I've traveled the tri-state area for work, and avoided chain eats as much as possible. I've found hundreds of wonderful mom-and-pops and holes in walls. Finding a unique spot to eat lunch is one of my favorite things. If you're a self respecting grinder shop, you better bring the Italian Combo. It's my first benchmark used to guage the menu. This is the best Italian Combo I've ever had. Sorry Nardelli's, (rated #1 nationally), you're number 2. Circle Pizza wins! Every trout fishing adventure would end here with an Italian Combo. We had to, no matter how late or tired. Luckily I have recently moved closer. Though, I have a small bout of depression if passing by without a stop. Everything on the menu is top notch. Eggplant parmesan also noteworthy. Their breakfast is amazing too, and has become a weekend staple. Thank you guys, for consistent and...

Really interesting and delicious pizza. Not being that familiar with Greek-style New England Pizza it was nice to finally put a name on a style of pie that I've enjoyed several times before. This is a pan-style pizza, sort of like a much higher quality version of Pizza Hut's signature pie. The ingredients in my pizza were fresh, the sauce was tasty and the crust was crispy and satisfying. It was definitely cheesy, maybe even a little too cheesy, making messy to eat with your hands. Luckily the cheese, like everything else in the pizza, seemed to be of better than average quality. As far as service goes it was very friendly. I was told it would be 20 minutes from my order to when my pizza would be ready and it was right on time....

Called the order in, told 20 mins to pickup. 20 minutes later, arrive to find that they had not even started to cook my order. 15-20 minutes later I had my order to go...at least it was hot. It would have been nice to be offered a discount or something extra for my trouble...all I got was a relatively lame excuse of being busy. Their definition of busy is a bit different than most places. The food is decent, hence not a 1 star review. This has happened more than once, they are now off the...