There are at least 3 of these in close proximity to one another. I tried 2 out of the 3. I wanted to be sure that it wasn't just the one I tried. NOPE! I just don't like it.
Out of the 3 - this one had great pics, so I thought maybe it would be better.
The customer service here was odd, but friendly. It was weirdbecause as I was waiting for my order, no one was out front cooking my food - no staff - I wondered is my food cooking???? Are they doing something to it they don't want me to see????
The food - in my opinion is not good. The pizza smelled funny. Not sure which ingredient, just didn't smell right. I was reluctant to try but I did and its the dough and sauce I do not like. Same at both. Not a fan.
I ordered fries as well. bland....but cooked, they had a slight crunch. So,I guess it was cooking.
For pizza - in the area - Giuffrida's Pizza is best (see my review for...
Read moreHey, you! Yeah, you! Haha Here's a little secret for ya, Saint Michael's Rusticana is the best pizza place in town.
I've had pizza at the other places around Saint Michael's, respectfully. But none compare to capturing that true New York Style pizza experience. All the ingredients come together just right. It's beautiful.
And don't get me started on Ms. Josie's secret recipe Eggplant Parmesan. I believe she's been making it for nearly 30 years. For me, that's their crown jewel. The best! Hands down. If I had the courage I'd ask how she does it. But knowing that it exists is good enough for me.
Overall, the biggest difference that counts the most are the owners, Josie and Carmine. They value their customers, they're genuine, and they make their cuisine with love from the heart. You can't go...
Read moreAs a regular here, I’m disappointed to say I will not come back. My frustration started with my Card notifying me that I had left a 78% tip on top of my $22 bill. Which was very incorrect. We went down there to resolve this issue and get our money back but The staff and owner were completely rude. They argued with us that they accidentally charged us incorrectly on our bill, and that it should have been more so they added it on through the tip once we left. Which is very illegal and the final total can’t be changed by the staff due to their fault. We finally got our money back after waiting 30 minutes. We loved coming here but if it wasn’t for my Card Notification I would have never known they added...
Read more