Wiseguys Pizzeria & Pub — Restaurant in Menasha

Your pizza is the best in north east Wisconsin hands down. The 50 min wait for the deep dish worth the wait. All your food and drinks are amazing.

Here comes why you don’t get five stars and to be honest if the food wasn’t so great, I might give out three stars.

Your service is not great. I’ve had a couple great experiences with staff, but mostly not the best. Now this is beyond staffing shortages and such. We are taking about folks that don’t understand the customer service industry.

We will overlook the mistakes made to orders. The establishment won’t be that busy and getting your order to be taken initially seems to be a task. I have actually recommended this place to multiple ppl and they have walked out due to not getting any service.

My prime example is a take out order I placed once. Waiting for my order I took a seat at the bar. I was there for 40 mins. That’s not my complaint. My complaint is they weren’t busy and I sat there for 40 mins at the bar and not once did the bar tender attempt to see if I wanted a drink. I planned on having two since I knew it was going to be a wait. No should I have maybe gotten their attention, sure. But I thought someone would’ve asked me if I wanted a drink. There was two other folks at the bar besides me.

Again food is amazing. Get the deep dish Dillanger.

And to the guy in the reviews complaining about oregano in the sauce…that’s called real sauce. That fella must want a can of...

Was craving pizza one night and decided to check this place out. I wish I had not waited so long! This is one of the best pizza places in the area!

Food- We got the Bar-B-Que Chicken pizza and a cheese pizza with garlic and tomatoes. The pizzas were awesome! The Bar-B-Que pizza was delicious! The sauce was just the right amount of sweet and tangy. Chicken was cooked perfectly. The cheese pizza was awesome as well. I got it with zesty sauce and it was packed with flavor. The crust on both pizzas was the right amount of crisp and chewy. It also had good flavor.

Drinks- There are a large amount of drinks to choose from. They have a full bar and many custom cocktails and martinis. They also have beer on tap and have bottled beer.

Service- Service is great. Pizza takes a little bit of time to cook but it wasn't long enough to make it annoying. We were checked on regularly and our drinks were filled whenever they got low. The server also had recommendations for us when we asked.

This is a great place to grab a pizza for either dine in or to go. The price is also comparable to other fresh pizza places...

We really wanted to love this place as it's a very cute restaurant and the staff is super friendly. However, the food is just not worth the price tag. The $8 cheesy garlic bread is two pieces of toast with mozzarella cheese slices melted on top and the deep dish pizza came out luke-warm without that special flavor that one would expect from a deep dish. One of the martinis I had was not drinkable and tasted like cleaning solution but the waitress did get me a different one which was a bit better. Again, the staff is VERY friendly and accommodating, nothing but good things to say there. Overall, we left spending $70 on a meal that we didn't feel satisfied with. There are many great pizza places in the Valley and unfortunately this is not one of them in my opinion. It could be an acceptable place for lunch or dinner if the prices came down...