Teddy's Pizza & Subs — Restaurant in Middleburg

There’s been a lot of hype about this pizza place. I never even noticed it, even though I pass by it frequently. It is tucked away in a rather dilapidated building that does not imply attention to hygiene. It does not inspire one to pay attention to it, let alone to order food. It happened to be open, I keep hearing the hype, so my kids and friends finally tried it.

It wasn’t my thing. It had a lot of cheese, which I appreciate but the crust was soggy in the center. Somehow they put pepperoni on our order and the guy implied that I probably said pepperoni as a slip. My kids are vegetarian…there was no slip by me. We did get another pizza and we were in no rush so I did not mind. Everyone was pleasant and kind, which I also appreciate. It was also fairly priced, I just did not like the pizza.

I can’t recommend the pizza. If you have tried it and like it, that makes me happy. Many people like it. I just think I don’t want pizza so much that I’ll order it again from here. It’s definitely not...

Drove all the way to Middleburg to try Teddy’s (the things you do for food…) and it did not disappoint. While the restaurant is fairly small, it easily accommodated my family and I.

The moment we entered, Teddy and company immediately struck a conversation with us. With NY roots, you can genuinely see their love for pizza and how it shines in the way they talk about their cooking process. They use all high-quality ingredients, ensuring each slice isn’t an oily mess like most pies you get elsewhere. In fact, for first time customers they give you one free cheese slice to try to really appreciate how they make their dough and sauce - which we really enjoyed.

We ordered a medium-sized meat lovers and it was surprisingly filling - was more than enough for myself and another. They were very generous with the toppings so each bite was packed with flavor.

Overall, really liked this establishment, a shame it’s such a trek for us. Though if you’re ever in Middleburg, be sure to check...

You really can't beat Teddy's for an authentic, homey, hole-in-the-wall NY pizza experience. Teddy is second to none on pizza knowledge and passion. His product is the result of his experience and enthusiasm for a great pie. Crispy crust of perfect thickness, vibrant house-made sauce, and the perfect amount of cheese and oil. While Teddy's earns its stripes on the merits of the cheese pizza alone, they'll gladly accommodate a topping and offer many. Granted, if your topping choices are of the Hawaiian persuasion, they may accommodate you reluctantly with the wit and sass of NY pizza vets. We came looking for great pizza but left with a laugh, an experience, hospitality, and fun memories from chatting the counter up while we waited. We...