HTML SitemapExplore
logo
Find Things to DoFind The Best Restaurants

Pagalo's Pizzeria & Gelato Cafe — Restaurant in Milan

Name
Pagalo's Pizzeria & Gelato Cafe
Description
Nearby attractions
Nearby restaurants
Maid-Rite
205 1st Ave W, Milan, IL 61264
Spinner's Pizza
319 1st Ave W, Milan, IL 61264
Hardee’s
US 67 &, 3rd Ave W, Milan, IL 61264
Two Sisters Restaurant
522 1st St W, Milan, IL 61264
Subway
313 1st Ave W, Milan, IL 61264
Dizzy Horse
432 1st Ave W, Milan, IL 61264
The Pub
426 1st Ave W, Milan, IL 61264
FINNS GRILL & BAR/ SWEET TREATS
527 2nd St W, Milan, IL 61264
McDonald's
400 1st St, Milan, IL 61264
Epic Eatz
580 1st St W, Milan, IL 61264
Nearby hotels
Related posts
Keywords
Pagalo's Pizzeria & Gelato Cafe tourism.Pagalo's Pizzeria & Gelato Cafe hotels.Pagalo's Pizzeria & Gelato Cafe bed and breakfast. flights to Pagalo's Pizzeria & Gelato Cafe.Pagalo's Pizzeria & Gelato Cafe attractions.Pagalo's Pizzeria & Gelato Cafe restaurants.Pagalo's Pizzeria & Gelato Cafe travel.Pagalo's Pizzeria & Gelato Cafe travel guide.Pagalo's Pizzeria & Gelato Cafe travel blog.Pagalo's Pizzeria & Gelato Cafe pictures.Pagalo's Pizzeria & Gelato Cafe photos.Pagalo's Pizzeria & Gelato Cafe travel tips.Pagalo's Pizzeria & Gelato Cafe maps.Pagalo's Pizzeria & Gelato Cafe things to do.
Pagalo's Pizzeria & Gelato Cafe things to do, attractions, restaurants, events info and trip planning
Pagalo's Pizzeria & Gelato Cafe
United StatesIllinoisMilanPagalo's Pizzeria & Gelato Cafe

Basic Info

Pagalo's Pizzeria & Gelato Cafe

119 1st Ave W, Milan, IL 61264
4.6(405)
Save
spot

Ratings & Description

Info

attractions: , restaurants: Maid-Rite, Spinner's Pizza, Hardee’s, Two Sisters Restaurant, Subway, Dizzy Horse, The Pub, FINNS GRILL & BAR/ SWEET TREATS, McDonald's, Epic Eatz
logoLearn more insights from Wanderboat AI.
Phone
(309) 787-5898
Website
pagalospizzeria.com

Plan your stay

hotel
Pet-friendly Hotels in Milan
Find a cozy hotel nearby and make it a full experience.
hotel
Affordable Hotels in Milan
Find a cozy hotel nearby and make it a full experience.
hotel
The Coolest Hotels You Haven't Heard Of (Yet)
Find a cozy hotel nearby and make it a full experience.
hotel
Trending Stays Worth the Hype in Milan
Find a cozy hotel nearby and make it a full experience.

Featured dishes

View full menu
Pagalo's Famous Breadsticks
Try an order of our most talked about appetizer from our wood-fired oven! Basket of 6 breadsticks, includes marinara sauce. Brushed with butter, with your choice of garlic salt, poppy seed or sesame seed.
Toasted Ravioli
12 toasted raviolis filled with italian sausage, baked in our wood-fired oven, sprinkled with parmesan cheese and served with our own marinara sauce.
Our Famous "Cricket Nachos"
Almost as popular as our breadsticks this appetizer is loaded with tortilla chips, taco flavored beef, melted jalapeño cheese, black olives, tomatoes & jalapeño. Sour cream available upon request.
Spinach Artichoke Dip
With crispy tortilla chips.
Baked Jalapeño Popper
Cream cheese filled jalapeño poppers baked, not fried in our wood-fired oven, served with a side of ranch dressing. 5 for.

Reviews

Things to do nearby

Business Analytics Certification (CBAP) Training in   Davenport, IA
Business Analytics Certification (CBAP) Training in Davenport, IA
Tue, Dec 9 • 9:00 AM
332 North Harrison Street, Davenport, IA 52801
View details
Quad Cities: Hyaluron Pen Training, Learn to Fill in Lips & Dissolve Fat!
Quad Cities: Hyaluron Pen Training, Learn to Fill in Lips & Dissolve Fat!
Tue, Dec 9 • 10:00 AM
4620 East 53rd Street #STE 200, Davenport, IA 52807
View details
Social Backgammon:  Beginners welcome
Social Backgammon: Beginners welcome
Tue, Dec 9 • 5:00 PM
3659 Devils Glen Road, Bettendorf, IA 52722
View details

Nearby restaurants of Pagalo's Pizzeria & Gelato Cafe

Maid-Rite

Spinner's Pizza

Hardee’s

Two Sisters Restaurant

Subway

Dizzy Horse

The Pub

FINNS GRILL & BAR/ SWEET TREATS

McDonald's

Epic Eatz

Maid-Rite

Maid-Rite

4.2

(474)

$

Click for details
Spinner's Pizza

Spinner's Pizza

4.5

(144)

Click for details
Hardee’s

Hardee’s

3.7

(309)

Click for details
Two Sisters Restaurant

Two Sisters Restaurant

4.5

(597)

Click for details
Get the Appoverlay
Get the AppOne tap to find yournext favorite spots!
Wanderboat LogoWanderboat

Your everyday Al companion for getaway ideas

CompanyAbout Us
InformationAI Trip PlannerSitemap
SocialXInstagramTiktokLinkedin
LegalTerms of ServicePrivacy Policy

Get the app

© 2025 Wanderboat. All rights reserved.
logo

Reviews of Pagalo's Pizzeria & Gelato Cafe

4.6
(405)
avatar
4.0
3y

I've had family in the cities my whole life and recently moved to Milan after a couple years in Silvis after growing up In Macomb. Trips to the cities ALWAYS involved pizza! When moved here, I made it a point to try all I could!💚 We are blessed with options! I have two go to's for QC style, and one for Chicago style.(one more i wanna try). My family loves pizza! Who doesn't? Momma was coming to visit. She happens to be my best friend as well, and of course the first topic of conversation is where are we going to eat? She left it up to me, but wanted Pizza! She wanted QC style. I chose Pagalos. I'd never been there but it's less than a half mile from me and I needed to put it on my list. NOT QC style! However,!!! OMFG! The crust... Light and crispy, but substantial. The sauce, flawless with a great garlic bite! The cheese. Oh the cheese♥️♥️♥️!!! Brick oven Pizza! It's a bit expensive. The service was good. Gelato is part of the name but it was never offered or suggested. I probably would have tried it. All in all...... Pagalos does their own thing. It's not like any other. And they do it well!...

   Read more
avatar
5.0
40w

I am so happy I found this place today after having a sudden attack craving for a margherita pizza. I would never have believed this place existed so close by and has been there for 25 years. I've lived in the QC for 4 years and haven't heard anyone mention it but when I got there around 4:30 on a Saturday, the parking lot was already almost packed. I sat at the bar and was waited on by the super kind Kendall who was helpful, quick and a joy to talk to. The pizza was delicious and exactly what I was craving with a little pepper and drizzle of olive oil over the top. The pistachio gelato was to die for. A perfect meal and experience and I can't wait to go back. Seems like the owners and staff have a great vibe and that is one of my favorite things when patroning a place. I also enjoy the owners' candid and frank responses to negative reviews on here. Shows a true dedication and commitment to their product and experiences. Have a good time and get...

   Read more
avatar
5.0
6y

I can't believe we had never been here before. Talk about a well kept secret!! We had the cheese ravioli and the meat sauce was the BEST BY FAR that I had EVER tasted; we also got the Italian Station pizza OMG my mouth WATERS just thinking about it. I'm usually a veggie lover when it comes to pizza especially; but I will have trouble ordering anything else after tasting this pizza. The flavors made my tastebuds DANCE AND COME ALIVE in a way that I didnt realize pizza could do. That's only a small piece of what they have to offer. Not only do they have a wonderfully large area for family dining that is in FULL VIEW OF THEIR WOOD FIRE OVEN, but theres also a bar on the other side of the wall as well as a room for slots and darts!! U would not even know that the bar and games were even there if u didnt go for a walk around or been told so if theres anyone sensitive to either or u dont want your family around such things you have no worries with this...

   Read more
Page 1 of 7
Previous
Next

Posts

Erin PhilpottErin Philpott
What a gem! Stumbled upon Pagalo's while road tripping through rural Illinois. We were greeted with kindness and wonderful hospitality. They have an amazing lunch deal. Very reasonable prices. We each got a 7in pizza. They were cheesy and fresh, and the crust was fluffy and crispy and just delightful. I also ordered the Wisconsin Cheese soup. I received a very generous portion, and even took some home with me. A lovely experience all around. Highly recommend. And I'm a Chicago and Rockford pizza girl, so I know good pizza!! Oh, and their bread sticks were lip smacking garlic salty!! ❤️
Todd Braun (The Food and Drink Guy)Todd Braun (The Food and Drink Guy)
Stopped here for lunch while in town based on a recommendation and really enjoyed the lunch. The restaurant was very clean and modern with nice decor (see pictures), the workers were all very friendly and the place was quite lively. I ordered the grilled chicken pizza (see picture) and really liked the seasoning, crust and overall flavor. Unfortunately, I didn't save room for gelato after the pizza...so will save that for the next visit. Food: 4 Atmosphere: 4 Value: 4 Service: 4 If you found this review helpful, please click to show your support. 👏🏼😎
rsng frcersng frce
Nice atmosphere. Very small selection of craft beers at a very fair price. The pizza cheese is excellent, however the crust is too thin and lacks any char, which I expect to find on a wood fired pizza. RESPONSE TO OWNER: from your previous responses, I gather that you preferred constructive criticism. However, if the way you have cooked pizzas has worked for 28 years as you say, best of luck to you and you've lost a customer based on your ARROGANT response.
See more posts
See more posts
hotel
Find your stay

Pet-friendly Hotels in Milan

Find a cozy hotel nearby and make it a full experience.

What a gem! Stumbled upon Pagalo's while road tripping through rural Illinois. We were greeted with kindness and wonderful hospitality. They have an amazing lunch deal. Very reasonable prices. We each got a 7in pizza. They were cheesy and fresh, and the crust was fluffy and crispy and just delightful. I also ordered the Wisconsin Cheese soup. I received a very generous portion, and even took some home with me. A lovely experience all around. Highly recommend. And I'm a Chicago and Rockford pizza girl, so I know good pizza!! Oh, and their bread sticks were lip smacking garlic salty!! ❤️
Erin Philpott

Erin Philpott

hotel
Find your stay

Affordable Hotels in Milan

Find a cozy hotel nearby and make it a full experience.

Get the Appoverlay
Get the AppOne tap to find yournext favorite spots!
Stopped here for lunch while in town based on a recommendation and really enjoyed the lunch. The restaurant was very clean and modern with nice decor (see pictures), the workers were all very friendly and the place was quite lively. I ordered the grilled chicken pizza (see picture) and really liked the seasoning, crust and overall flavor. Unfortunately, I didn't save room for gelato after the pizza...so will save that for the next visit. Food: 4 Atmosphere: 4 Value: 4 Service: 4 If you found this review helpful, please click to show your support. 👏🏼😎
Todd Braun (The Food and Drink Guy)

Todd Braun (The Food and Drink Guy)

hotel
Find your stay

The Coolest Hotels You Haven't Heard Of (Yet)

Find a cozy hotel nearby and make it a full experience.

hotel
Find your stay

Trending Stays Worth the Hype in Milan

Find a cozy hotel nearby and make it a full experience.

Nice atmosphere. Very small selection of craft beers at a very fair price. The pizza cheese is excellent, however the crust is too thin and lacks any char, which I expect to find on a wood fired pizza. RESPONSE TO OWNER: from your previous responses, I gather that you preferred constructive criticism. However, if the way you have cooked pizzas has worked for 28 years as you say, best of luck to you and you've lost a customer based on your ARROGANT response.
rsng frce

rsng frce

See more posts
See more posts