Maria's Pizza Milltown — Restaurant in Milltown

EDIT 10/24: they dropped off a flyer, haven’t tried them in a while.

“Order on our website and save” it doesn’t work. Alternative, link to Grubhub and not paying $32 for a $23 pizza plus tip.

Website says “delivery approximately 105 minutes” and still doesn’t work. Why spend money on flyers when you can’t take orders?

Back to our regular place we use every week (through DD). Sad bc wanted to check y’all out again.

——-

Welcome to Milltown, with more pizza per capita than about any place on earth!

Maria's has been a fixture of the local scene for years. They make a decent pie, no surprises, nothing out of the ordinary.

Interestingly, the menus go out of their way to state "not affiliated with Vinnie's Pizza". Hmmm, small-town drama, anyone? It doesn't say "not affiliated with Dusal's" (or Francesco, or Pasquale, or Shanahan's, or even Domino's!) which makes this all the more interesting. What's this all about? The drama is probably more interesting...

I visited Maria’s hoping for a quick run in to get some dough to make pizzas at home with the family. The pizzeria was moving.

Unfortunately, the experience was soured by one of the staff members who was extremely rude from the moment I walked in( shorter fellow behind the counter black slick back hair, he is always there). He seemed annoyed just by taking any orders, didn’t greet me, and responded to simple questions with a dismissive tone. It felt like I was a bother for even showing up.

As someone who values respectful and friendly service — even just basic politeness — this really put me off. I understand people have bad days, but this seemed like a consistent attitude, not a one-time thing. Hence why I just get dough and go home and make it with the kids.

I won’t be returning unless the management addresses the staff’s customer service. Good food isn’t enough to make up for being...

First time i order from them was last Sunday. Ordered sausage pizza (i received the order details in my email correct) got a plain pizza! ordered wings with hot sauce got sweet BBQ sauce , all drums wings, received a mixed! i was able to mention about the wrong pie to the delivery lady (she was nice enough to say next order will be on the house) however, i also called and spoke to the store manger or owner (lady answered the phone) and she also apologized and said the same thing next order will be on the house! i called today a week later today 7/20/19 after i was put on hold right-away (i am guessing they are busy) told the gentleman on the phone the story and if they will honor that, he rudely said " she is not here now" and hung up very poor customer service guys. Terrible customer service and never going to order anything...