Di Stefano's Pizza Palace — Restaurant in Milwaukee

Cozy little, no frills, south side Milwaukee pizza joint. Takeout only, the inside feels nostalgic and reminiscent of old school pizza places with the right amount of Italian American kitsch. Friendly staff, you can tell this place is family owned and operated and that they really care about providing a quality product.

We had the bosco sticks, a sausage and cheese pizza as well as a chocolate covered cannoli! Everything was very tasty and reasonably priced. I highly recommend the bosco sticks, they were cheese filled breadsticks that paired perfectly with marinara sauce. Pizza was solid, sauce is on the sweet side which I know is more a matter of preference so I won’t knock it for that! The chocolate cannoli was very good and encourage you to order at least one as the perfect way to finish your meal!

Highly recommend Di Stefano’s if you’re in the mood for non pretentious, cozy, Italian...

They have the best pizza. You can tell it's an old family recipe and I'm so happy they share it with other Wisconsinites. My BF loves their sausage and they're definitely not stingy on the toppings. If you like pepperoncini, I'd recommend trying theirs. Tastes homemade. The best is if you cook it at 450 on a hot pizza pan for 7 minutes to add an extra crunch. Started doing this because of Covid 19 & I'm happy I did. I always get the same thing and will never get sick of it...ham, onion, pepperoncini, & ricotta cheese. Yum yum. Writing this I'm making myself hungry. This is a must try if you want authentic homemade pizza. Also forgot about their salads. Their creamy Italian is awesome! Goes so good with any pizza. Had a Hawaiian pizza for the 1st time and it's definitely unique....

Garbage overpriced pizza! Tastes like all the cheap chain pizza joints. To make up for lousy pizza sauce, it is filled with sugar so it takes like candy. The thin crust is terrible. Tastes like nothing...cardboard. The toppings are so minuscule that they look like Barbie made them. What a ripoff. Just goes to show the terrible taste buds that Wisconsinites have...and what they think is great. The 50 years that they have been in business proves my point. Their customers have never eaten really good pizza. Will never, never, ever buy food from Di Stefano's again. Look at my photo. That is a 12" pizza. You need a magnifying glass to see the green bell pepper. And where did they import the midget...