Pisanos Pizza — Restaurant in Muskogee

This is a hidden gem that's worth a visit, despite its unassuming exterior.

I'll be honest; when you first look at the place from the outside, it doesn't scream "pizza paradise." However, don't let the appearance fool you. Inside, you'll find a delightful surprise—a pizza buffet that serves some seriously good pies.

The pizza at Pisanos is undoubtedly the star of the show. The crust is perfectly crispy, and the toppings are fresh and flavorful. I couldn't get enough of their pizza, and it was clear that they take pride in their craft.

My only minor disappointment was the limited variety on the buffet. While the pizza options were fantastic, it would have been nice to see a broader range of choices, including some non-pizza items to cater to different tastes.

Now, let's talk about the price. Pisanos is a bit on the pricey side for a pizza buffet, especially considering the overall quality of the food. However, the taste of the pizza somewhat justifies the cost.

Despite the price and limited variety, I would definitely return to Pisanos when I'm in the area. The pizza was a pleasant surprise, and it's clear that they prioritize quality over quantity. If you're a pizza lover willing to overlook the exterior and willing to pay a little extra for great taste, Pisanos Pizza is...

New owners of this place absolutely do not know how to run a business and I’m sure they are actively running a historically amazing resturant into the ground with their service. This has happened to me FOUR TIMES in the past 6 months and this is ultimately why I will not be back.

We called at 4:45 pm today (12/21/2024) and asked when would be a good time to call and order since we know they like to close at random times without any warning and does not follow their listed business hours of closing at 9 pm. We called and they said to call at 7:00 because they were thinking of closing at 8:00 or 7:30 so they said 7:00 would be perfect. Go to call them at 6:55 pm to place the order because we had family coming in. Called 5 times and it goes straight to voicemail every time. I run over there to place the order in person and guess what. CLOSED! We literally had called earlier to make sure this does not happen and of course it happens. This is ridiculous and absolute laziness. I don’t know how this place stays in business. The owners need to sell this place and hopefully the next person can run...

We came in after lunch and the buffet was kinda bare but they were so quick and willing to get whatever we would like made and on it. The only downer was they were out of rigatoni noodles and it would be around 5 or 6pm before more would be teady. They were out of Dr. Pepper on the fountain and immediately fixed it for us. The salad bar was freshly filled. The employees were absolutely awesome!!! The atmosphere was great. The booth seats are very well used and could use refurbishing but it did not detract from...