The Slice — Restaurant in New Albany

Recently opened. The decor lacks and they try to make up for it with live TV's all over the place. Not homey per se. The music is loud so you can't really hear your convo very well. That being said, none of that matters because if it's only the food that you seek, then come here. The pizza is wonderful. The tomato sauce is flavorful and the crust is perfect with seasoning. They had tiny cups of pickled carrots, celery and mini cauliflower. The potato bites were 2x times the volume of a normal tater tot. Think a warm twice baked potato encased in a tater tot. The nacho cheese that paired with it tasted like it had vinegar or pickled juice in it. Not the best kick and I think it could be toned down. But the tee time taters were good by themselves. Overall great. Lots of younger kids on staff. Small bar in back. Gluten free options are good with a cauliflower crust and a ciderboys grand mimosa. Husband liked his wheat free pizza. We tried this over 812 Pizza Co. this year. I hope it lasts until next year! Because we would come back. ✌️ I'm going to deduct 1 star because you simply cannot get one salad to go (Mulligan Medley) on their menu..boo hoo. Lord knows why. If it's the prosciutto, just remove it. No root beer, tapped out. Beer to go in...

Went to The Slice tonight for their Trivia Night and had so much fun with my daughter and friends. This cool new pizza joint has some of the best pizza I have ever had, truly. Honestly just the pizza crust alone will have me coming back!! Tonight I tried the “fairway fungi” to start, the white cheddar Alfredo was creamy and had a lot of flavor! The Parmesan panko topping was a perfect crispy touch. My daughter had the kids pasta with red sauce and a side of chips. Good portion and price for a kids meal. I had the Bethpage White pizza (picture attached) and it absolutely did not disappoint. Very cheesy and creamy. Also a great price for such a filling pizza. Honestly I still just can’t get over that crust!! Then we finished with the cream cheese brownie. You know it’s gonna be good when it comes out in that mini cast iron skillet!! Perfect portion size dessert for 2-3 people. So delicious! The staff were very friendly, our bartender/server Kenzie was very attentive and helpful, even with a full house! Food came out promptly and accurate. Highly recommend this little gem...

The customer is always right, unless you order a pizza from these folks. Called for a pickup and was told they couldn’t do a half/half on their “major” pizzas, but I could ORDER a custom 1/2 & 1/2. Ok, so we try that….nope we cant even accommodate the custom order.

Seriously, you’re new to the neighborhood why would you alienate customers like this? Don’t tell me you won't do a 1/2 and 1/2 unless its “custom” only to tell me you won't do that either. It’s pizza folks, its not that hard (and yours isn’t so good you should be telling people these things).

And to their response, I didn’t ask for vanilla ice cream on one side and marinara on the other, how childish. We simply asked for a 1/2-1/2 with similar toppings but were told “no”. Their response hardly even warrants this edit, it’s pizza for god sake, not art.

Hard pass...