Daniel's Pizzeria — Restaurant in New Brunswick

I have heard tales of the fabled Daniel's pizzeria for over a year before I tried it. The pizzeria is a hole in the wall and it shares its space with an asian food / sushi establishment. There are exactly two tables, one of them broken, so if you lean on it, it might collapse. The fridge is stocked with water, coke, sprite, or diet, all the sodas being in cans. Parking is non-existant and if it weren't for the bland, zero-frills sign, you wouldn't even know there was a pizzeria in the building. All of that being said, this pizza is some of the best I've had in the New Brunswick area. The plain slice was crispy and the crust had perfect crunch. The cheese and sauce is fresh and delicious. The herbs and spices are subtle and not overpowering. The cheese steak slice tasted like cheese steak I used to eat on boy scout camping trips years ago, but honestly, it didn't compare to the penne vodka slice. The penne vodka slice was absolutely delicious. I don't really ever go for the pasta pizza, but the sauce was thick and creamy and truly a tasty blend. Though it was a little on the salty side, it was far better than I could have imagined at first glance. This leads me to conclude that Daniel's pizza is a hidden gem among New Brunswick Pizza and serves a great specialty slice. Though there's not much room to sit and the drink options are far from plentiful, this pizza is a pleasant surprise in a town of pizzerias that caters to the...

If you’re at Rutgers University or around New Brunswick, Daniel’s Pizzeria is a standout pizza spot that’s well-loved by students and locals alike. Located right on Easton Ave, Daniel’s offers pizza by the slice, famously featuring very thin crust slices that nail the balance: crunchy on the outside, yet soft inside. The sauce is a highlight—many reviews rave about its fresh, flavorful kick, making every bite memorable.

Customer service at Daniel’s Pizzeria repeatedly gets high marks; staff are attentive, friendly, and keep things running smoothly, making your order-in or grab-and-go experience pleasant every time.

Dave Portnoy, the Barstool Sports founder and social media personality, dropped by Daniel’s while filming at Rutgers for the Barstool College Football Show. On his “One Bite” YouTube channel, Portnoy praised the pizzeria’s quality, especially for a college pie, and rated it a solid 7.2 out of 10, noting the crust’s thin crunch and the sauce’s strength.

Whether you grab a Margherita, tomato, or a plain slice, Daniel’s impresses with choices and quality toppings. The local favorite earns its top recs—and if you’re chasing exceptional thin-crust pizza near Rutgers, Daniel’s Pizzeria should be...

Best pizza in New Brunswick, hands down. I’d honestly say that Daniel’s is my favorite pizza of all time. The margherita is divine, with a fresh and flavorful sauce, but there is nothing that compares to the vodka sauce. I have tried several other penne vodka pizzas in the area, but nothing compares to Daniel’s. It’s my go-to comfort food, and I take everyone I can there. If you only try one pizza place while in New Brunswick, you have to come to Daniel’s.

Edit: I was so lost in the sauce that I forgot to mention that the crust is literally everything I’ve ever wanted in a pizza crust. Thin and crispy, just the right amount of oil, and with a perfect flavor. You can tell that I’m obsessed with this place.

Edit #2: Daniel’s tomato pie (a new addition) surpasses the margherita, as far as I’m concerned. I’m officially declaring that Daniel’s is the best pizza there is, and I don’t care how many New Yorkers are offended because...