Armetta's Pizzeria & Pub — Restaurant in New Milford Township

Dined in today on September 20,2025 Greeted at front door told to take a seat anywhere waitress met us at the table and asked for our drinks! Which was perfect she quickly took the rest of our order which again perfect. Here’s when it goes down hill, we ordered fried raviolis and they were honestly the worst fried ravioli I’ve ever had. All you could taste was a greasy breaded layer. No flavor whatsoever then we ordered the garlic knots They were OK subpar at the most. We also ordered a specialty pizza 1/2 being meat lovers other half being a white pizza with tomato, spinach, ricotta, and garlic on it. Specifically asked no onions on the white side of the pizza. as we are sitting there waiting for our pizza to come out, which was a longer wait, but we were OK with that because we figured we could make conversation and talk about our days instead and obnoxious customer behind us talked so loud she was practically screaming the entire time we couldn’t even hear ourselves think so then yes the weight got very annoying as all we wanted to do was get out of there. Finally, my husband and I got sick and tired of it, and I went up to the waitress and asked for our pizza to be to go. Probably five minutes later, the waitress comes out with our pizza in our Bill $55 for our meal so $10 for the fried raviolis which were horrible five dollars for the garlic knots again subpar. Then we had two sodas so on average I wanna say that was probably 20 bucks for the appetizers and drinks that leaves $35 For the pizza, we open the pizza covered in onions after we specifically asked no onions. We did let the hostess know about how we didn’t mind the wait but the obnoxious was the problem she proceeds to tell me the customer is in all the time and does the same thing. So clearly has never acknowledged the fact it’s bad...

I’m a truck driver. Parked at the truck stop 200 yards up the road. Looked at the menu posted from a year ago. Saw some subs for $9.00, looked good, placed the order for delivery since I didn’t want to leave the truck unattended. 2 subs. I figure $20 with tax. They won’t bring the food to the truck, which I get for safety reasons. So I walk across the lot, get handed a bill for $30. I know the poor girl delivering doesn’t set the prices so I tipped her $5.00. Then I had to ask. How did the price go up $10? You can tell she was embarrassed. I guess subs went up $1.00 each, fine. Business must be booming, $1.00 credit card fee, $4.00 delivery fee and $3.00 because they put the tip in automatically. She let me glance at the itemized bill. None of this was explained on the phone. I’m 100’ from a Burger King but tried to support a locally owned small business. But they saw a trucker as Easy money. Teaches me not to ask questions before placing an order anywhere. I wonder if the extra few bucks skimmed was worth a lost customer. Gave 2 stars because the food is decent, was on time and the delivery girl was sweet

Good lord. Seeing how this business attacks negative reviews. Now it’s all making sense how they treat truckers. I just for fun went down to see what other folks had to say. Amazing. Can’t wait to see how they come at me. After seeing how the owner responds to criticism I need to make this one star. It’s...

Placed an order this evening and when we went to picked it up received the wrong pies called her brought them back. She had a bad attitude was very defensive like it was my fault. They gave me the wrong pizzas. Ordered two pizzas got two wrong pizzas And looking at my bill and comparing the cost on the menu she way overcharged me. How could you order two pizzas one was $17 the other was 23 and my credit card bill says $65. FYI, my order was one large plain cheese, pizza and one double stuffed crust steak and cheese pizza. That does not come to $65 pay attention people and by the way, the one small pizza that we did keep because somebody grabbed a piece of it was like a flat piece of cardboard covered in grease. Thank you for ripping me off! I was warned that the pizza was hit or miss here anymore and every time I’ve ordered from here it just keeps going downhill like the service if I could give a zero rating I would. won’t be returning, but I’m sure you don’t care not with the...