Domenico's Pizza & Pasta — Restaurant in New York

I've had food from Domenico's to varying degrees over the last decade. I specifically remember finding the place to be decent to lower quality. I specifically stopped going there in person when I got the hottest slices of my life. It was so hot the entire slices themselves were nearly completely melted with much of what composed the slices sliding off the slices like water and scalding me multiple times. Eating it was just as much of a struggle. Occasionally, my friends ordered from here. My impression of it from those experiences was that everything was excessively greasy. I would go as far as say that Domenico's has the greasiest pizza I ever tasted. The buffalo slices were serviceable but kind of subpar, like a 4/10 I would rate it. From my memories and later experiences the pepperoni and generic slices were either decent or kind of undesirable something between a 6/10 to a 3/10 at times I found. The garlic knots were pretty good but again, were excessively greasy which could occasionally jeopardize the experience of having them. I should also warn that if you intend to eat there, that it's an extremely small pizzeria, one of the smallest I ever been to from my memory.

Ultimately, I think of Domenico's as a pizzeria that could be described as either decent or subpar. The greasiness and that one experience I had with the hottest slices on the planet are what caused me to round what would be a 2.5 out of 5 to just a 2 here. It has the potential to be a pleasant experience, it's just sometimes it genuinely is an...

Worst pizza on all of Staten Island from staff to the deliver drivers no respect for the customer waited more then a hour for my food just to get it and only eat one slice and 3 mozzarella sticks !!!! The pie was completely falling apart from the sauce to the cheese to the chicken the slices were all cut unevenly mozzarella sticks tasted like they put them in the microwave for 10 min and when I called for the first time ever asking for a refund and I offered for them to come pick the food back up I had the owner calling me trying to tell me I’m wrong in this situation and denied my request for a refund DONT BUY FROM HERE YOU WILL WASTE YOUR MONEY AND BE...

The entire staff, especially Chris (the MVP) were so polite and helpful. He even carried my pizzas to my car and was super patient with me. I had never gotten food there before but my mom was at the local hospital and I am so grateful I chose Domenico's for their proximity but learned that they have a lot more going for them than that. The security staff at the hospital and the ICU staff were pleased with their pizzas and I thank you greatly for all you did to get my order ready even more quickly than I was told. My mom loved the eggplant parm hero I got for her (and not just because it beats...