Domino's Pizza — Restaurant in Newburgh

Let me start off by saying I've never had any bad experiences with this location. The last time I ordered there was a mix up and I was delivered the wrong pizza, stuff happens, the pizza was hot so that was no issue at all. I absolutely hate complaining or saying negative things like this but tonight I ordered a pizza for me and my son because it's friday, I'm a working mom and I'm feeling lazy. The pizza was hot and delicious, I ordered a cheese with extra pineapple. It's my sons favorite and I don't really like meat so it's a nice texture change. I bit into whatever this was. I kept chewing but it wasn't breaking apart. I spit it out and looked at it and i was like oh this is just cheese...but why is it so chewy??? I'm a little worried now and hope this wasn't something not meant for consumption. 4 stars because I don't want to be a jerk about this. Things happen, but i am a little concerned as I can't identify...

I order from this Domino’s a ridiculous number of times in any given time period and have for a number of years. The output from this location is above all else quality and consistent. My biggest gripe was that any sauces for my order wouldn’t arrive with my order- even if I put a note in the delivery notes box. Management explained it was a flaw with how their system printed out orders, but I can say this issue has seemingly resolved itself and I’ve not had this be an issue for awhile now. Their drivers are prompt and friendly. If there was ever an issue with an order, management always made it right whether with a new delivery or store credit. I’m a night owl and appreciate their later delivery times when nothing around me for 15+ miles is still open, they have been there too save the day. Highly recommend this location in particular and...

Dominos in evansville (1st ave) was soooo bad I literally un-installed Domino's from my phone. Then I moved to Newburgh and decided to try them again. I haven't gotten a pizza that both looked so good and tasted so good from Domino's since moving to indiana. This one on State St in Newburgh is doing it right! Great pizza and the delivery guy was amazing. Good people, good food and good prices. I purposely got a thin crust bc I was craving it amd those pizzas suck to make I imagine bc nono have been good up here yet. Maybe it's just evansville and all of the chemical related extracurricular activities they're up to idk but Newburgh is on point! But I'd be willing to be this Domino's has a decent manager that doesn't hire any heartbeat that...