By The Bay Creamery — Restaurant in Ocean City

Indulging in the delightful flavors at this great little ice cream shop was truly a treat and surprise! From classic favorites to unique and artisanal creations that are nowhere to be found in OC except at By the Bay creamery. I personally had a sundae and tried 2 scoops of their signature favors. One scoop was PB Hearts Chocolate which is peanut butter ice cream with chocolate fudge and peanut butter cups. The other scoop was Exhausted Parent which is Bourbon spiked espresso ice cream folded with bittersweet chocolate chunks!! Every scoop was a burst of creamy perfection and one of a kind which has me craving this place all the time! One thing noted was how quick the orders and the line out the door was moving through due to the friendly staff that knew all the ice cream by heart and each order was made prompt and no mistakes which was impressive and made the experience even more enjoyable. Whether you're a fan of traditional flavors or feeling adventurous, this custom family owned creamery has something for everyone. A must-visit for any ice cream enthusiast looking to satisfy their ice cream...

Cute, family friendly ice cream shop.

My cousin and I were driving through ocean city and noticed By The Bay Creamery had just opened so we swung in for a couple scoops.

My cousin got a large (should’ve been called MASSIVE) bowl with some raspberry cheesecake flavor (sorry the name escapes me) and he tore that stuff up! I got my dad the mint mudslide milkshake, it was a little thick with the Oreo in the flavor but they have those big milkshake straws that are essential to any seasoned milkshake drinker.

I was a little worried for myself coming in, because of some dietary restrictions I’m dealing with, but the very helpful young women at By the Bay Creamery easily helped me pick out a flavor that had no sugar added and even that was surprisingly scrumptious.

I would highly recommend By the Bay Creamery, whether you’re a local like myself looking for a sweet treat after a long day of work, or someone visiting looking to indulge on vacation, By the Bay Creamery has some of the best ice cream flavors we’ve tried recently. In a town saturated with ice cream shops, my go to choice...

My son and I stumbled upon this Creamery during a walk from our rental on 67th street up to 94th street. We were interested in trying some super premium ice cream. We were not disappointed.

My son wanted the Ultimate Oreo while I wanted to try the Fat Elvis and the This $@&! Just Got Serious. I had to get a medium for 2 flavors which was fine and my son got a small. I spoke with the owners daughter who was serving us. She gave us some info about the store. She said they just opened up in 2024 on Memorial Day and that they were looking a possible other locations in OCMD and other states but this was their only current location.

The ice cream was fantastic. You can really taste the difference. I am shocked that with the quality ingredients along with being certified Kosher the ice cream was super affordable. It is not cheaper anywhere else. Both Dumser's and King Kone are about the same price for a more mass produced ice cream. I know I went to all 3 locations in 2024.

Give this small business a try and taste...