Old Chicago Pizza Delivery & Takeout — Restaurant in Petaluma

Save your $50+. Do not come here. Staff was pleasant for the pick up only service, but the pizza was horrible. Tasted like two day old pre-made crust that they threw toppings on and put in the oven to try to revive. My daughter went as far to say that Chuck-E-Cheese pizza was better than this. Disappointing for order-out pizza. On top of that, they tried to offer up a "better salad" price matched to my basic dinner salad. Seemed to be an old salad from earlier that didn't get sold or picked up. When turned down, the employee then went and said she would go make our salad - mind you, order was placed 40 minutes prior to arrival so they just didn't plan on making the salad in hopes that we would take the old salad. This whole experience really just shows that they really put the OLD in Old Chicago Pizza. You're better off...

Let me tell you about my go-to for pizza night: Old Chicago Pizza's takeout location. 🍕 Yes, their deep dish is already legendary, but what seals the deal for me? They deliver right to my doorstep. And not just any pizza, but THE best pizza you could ask for, with that unbeatable sauce and dreamy ranch.

My must-have order? Pepperoni, Canadian bacon, sausage, jalapeño, pineapple, and red onion on top. It's the kind of combo that turns a regular evening into a flavor fiesta. Even my friends who are 'pineapple on pizza' skeptics make an exception for Old Chicago. It's that delicious.

Seriously, having this gem deliver to my house has been a game changer. Cozy nights in just got a whole lot tastier. If you haven’t tried their delivery yet, you’re missing out on the convenience of pizza perfection coming right to you. Best...

First off best Pizza ever!! Priced a little high so this is not your typical go to Pizza joint, this is a once and awhile spot. The only bad words I have for OC is that they say they close at 8:30 but guess again, they actually stop taking orders at 7:59, if it’s 8 or 8:02 they tell you to kick rocks. No where on their site, in the store, anywhere does it mention this; just closes at 8:30. So if you forget this or it’s been awhile since you’ve ordered there and you call at 8 or after you are out of luck. I can’t tell you how many times I’ve called just after 8 and heard no more orders, well they lose my business and I get my pizza fix somewhere else and then it will be another long while until I order from them again… maybe it’s partly my fault but just put closes at 8...