Second time visiting, second time disappointed. They make very good macaroons, but the consistency of their other goods seems to be hit or miss.
My first visit, I purchased three items as a taste test for me and my friend. Two macaroons, one oatmeal, cream pie, and a very small cake (they’d sold out of white cupcakes by the time we’d arrived). The macaroons were very good as was the oatmeal cream pie, but the cake was very dry/stale and most of it ended up getting thrown away.
I had told a couple people how good the oatmeal cream pies were, and decided to surprise them with some this week. I was there first thing on Tuesday morning (they are closed Sunday and Monday) and nothing was out except a couple trays of cupcakes and the macaroons. Figuring they had been baking early that morning and just didn’t have time to put things out, I asked if they had any oatmeal cream pies. They went in the back and brought out a plastic container from the refrigerator. I was charged $15 for four cookies that were so stale two of them ended up in the trash. I even tried letting them get to room temp, but it didn’t help. Very disappointing as I had talked them up so much.
Unfortunately, I won’t be returning to this bakery. For the price they are charging, consistency should...
Read moreWow fantastic product! The app is adorable and the owner is extremely friendly and personable. I tried macarons and cupcakes, and think both are with every penny. And both refrigerate extremely well.
The macarons are jam-packed with flavor! Whatever flavor you choose, you will be blown away. Lavender was packed with flavor, as was the rose. The asked caramel actually has gooey caramel filling!
The cupcake icing/frosting is impeccable. It's smooth and creamy, not too sweet, and very flavorful.
The only thing i didn't like we the cupcake box. I think it's a bit too large for the cupcakes. But everything...
Read moreBake Me Treats made the cake for our wedding in May 2022 and it was perfect! I waited to book a bakery until fairly late in the wedding planning process (we booked in March for a May wedding), but Bake Me Treats was still available and able to offer delivery as well.
The cake was delicious and also beautiful! We aren’t sure if we’ll be able to save the top tier for our one year anniversary because we might not want to wait that long to eat it! Gabriele delivered the cake right on schedule, it looked beautiful, and it tasted great! I would definitely recommend Bake Me Treats for...
Read more