Pizzaiolo Italian Eatery — Restaurant in Raynham

I really wish I could give these guys the full five stars their food is excellent.

My last 3 visits have been troublesome. 1st : I was missing items on a delivery order and had to go pick up the missing item 2nd : I came to pickup an order and completely on accident it was dropped and needed to be remade (no problems it happens glad I was not eating floor food, great integrity) 3rd : I'm left to assume by the shock on the poor front counter tenants face that my food was handed to another gentleman because I could see they were remaking mine... My issue is I paid for a sandwich with extra ingredients that I did not get on it... And it wasn't roasted as I had asked for.

It seems that every visit I make, I just don't get my order on time, as requested...

Updated June 2025

I've been regularly ordering from here for about 3 months now and can honestly say it's a complete turn around.

The Staff has been on point, attentive and kind. They feel like friends when I call/walk-in. The order is almost always ready ahead of the expected time!

Their accuracy on the orders has been remarkable and the food has been delicious. The pizza, salads and sandwich that I usually order always tastes great and notably the meat/cheese is FRESH...

I wish I could give this place 0 stars seriously. I am going to start off with saying that I used to be a very big fan of Pizzaiolo until recently. I have been coming here since they opened but the quality of food AND service has gone GROSSLY DOWNHILL. First off, this business cannot keep a consistent staff to save their life, every time I go in there it is new staff.... what does that tell you about the management?! There used to be a few very nice girls who worked upfront, they were very friendly, attentive, and always knew my order but recently I can see that they left and its obvious with the service you receive. The cooks must have also left. I used to LOVE their pasta it was made by a very kind foreign man who would always say hi to me when I come in, assuming he left too because pasta is garbage. Pizza is always greasy and the chicken fingers are always poorly cooked. Biggest waste of your money honestly dont even bother. Oh and the owner is rude and takes no responsibility for anything.

Edit - I would also like to add that I left this review two days ago and have received no response from management. Also tried calling the store and was hung-up on when I stated that I would like to speak to management regarding...

This review is several years in the making, and I don't know why I have waited this long to sing their praises. The quality of this shop beats everyone in the area, and feels more like a sandwich shop on Atwells Avenue than Route 44 and Raynham. Their consistency and quality is what sets them apart. People seem to whine about the counter service or time for food or prices. Everyone needs to wake up, running a small business is very difficult and they operate on razor thin margins to simply sustain a living...this is clearly a family business that is trying to survive with sky high food prices and insane costs of labor. Would it be better if they had an army waiting at the counter or one behind to prepare it faster, maybe... maybe not. I ordered a small chicken cutlet sub today with roasted red peppers, fresh mozzarella, basil and balsamic. Every single ingredient was fresh and flavorful...it felt like I was eating a sandwich for the first time...and I assure the reader it was not. I'm no connoisseur, but I've had them on the streets of Italy and all the heavy hitters between New York and Boston. On the right day, this place could hold its own with...