Rehoboth Baking Co — Restaurant in Rehoboth

Updated review from 5 to 2 stars

I’ve been a customer since they were at the country store. At first it was great, and I’d come very often and promoted it to friends and online. But I’ve noticed the quality keeps going down hill. First it would something small like the cookie or cream puff being so overcooked it would be hard as a rock. Then the pizza would be almost burnt or barely any sauce despite a request for heavy sauce. Tonight, I figured I’d bring some friends as I wanted to sit outside. I was very specific about no peppers on my sandwich. Can’t do them. Got part way through the sandwich & saw the peppers… and a pepper seed. Really have to avoid them. So I gave the rest to the friends.I hate to do this to a place I once loved and went to every other week but that’s where we are at.

I was a fan when it was just based out of the country store. I’m an even bigger fan now that they’ve opened the restaurant.

Firstly, their pizza is divine. You can get 3 types of crust- bar pizza, New Haven, and Detroit. Each are wonderful and homemade. I also love the red sauce they make which can make or break a pizza; theirs is outstanding.

Their sandwiches all come on their homemade bread & again, just delicious.

If you have a sweet tooth, I highly recommend their desserts. My favorite is their bread pudding.

There is always a steady stream of customers and I can see why. It’s a great place. Everyone who works there is...

I've been following Rehoboth Baking on Instagram for a while and finally made my way there and am kicking myself for not getting there sooner. Sort of tucked away in a rural town in southeastern Massachusetts, Rehoboth baking offers a remarkable menu and a cool, little atmosphere that makes any drive worth it.

You order your food at the counter and the restaurant has sandwiches, pizzas, baked goods and more. The worst part about the place is picking what you want to eat because everything sounds absolutely amazing.

I opted for a pizza cooked in Detroit style with roasted chicken, pesto and ricotta. The pizza had the great, doughy Detroit feel complete with crispy sides. You can order pizza in either Detroit, New Haven or bar pizza styles. Really good stuff. My dining friends each had a different chicken sandwich, one a chicken parm and the other with lettuce, tomato and pickles, and both sandwiches were served on an amazingly fresh made roll. Rave reviews on all the food.

We took home some sourdough English muffins and blueberry muffins for breakfast tomorrow and the focaccia and loaves of bread all looked incredible.

Definitely will be back to try more from this place soon enough and would recommend you check...

2nd time here - came for dessert to take home after grabbing lunch at Campfire Tavern. Grabbed a PB Square and mounding Chocolate Creme Pie. Didn't pay attention to how it was packaged and was a little disappointed when we got home to see it was smushed into a flat-top pie tin. Don't get me wrong, it still tasted great and is totally worth getting again, I'd probably just eat it there, or ask for it in an open top container if they didn't have anything that fit it well.

1st timer here - can't wait to go back! Had the steak, egg & cheese sandwich on sourdough and a pineapple lemongrass refresher. I would reorder both! On our way out, I grabbed a strawberry rice krispie treat and a creme puff (they were both huge!). The rice krispie treat was marshmallow heavy and worth trying. The creme puff was really good, but a little messy to eat -...